Rosemary

Jan 13th, 500 p.d.

“You’re running out of time.”

The paladin fiddled with the cotton laces of his gambeson and studied the gilded railings of the massive staircase below him, each of the thousands of rungs thin arms that reached from concrete to grasp the tawny bar that ran three hundred meters down to the city. Rows of opportunistic rosemary lined the hilltop on each side of the long staircase, thick branches curving wildly and permeating the air with their earthy odor. With the early morning fog that covered the church on its tall hilltop, obscuring the furthermost steps that staggered endlessly below them, it looked as though they were sitting at the gates of heaven.

“I’ll tell him tonight then. Better if it came from me,” he said as if he had not already argued this point many times before.

The woman to his right let out an exasperated huff, for a moment distracted from gnawing at the nail on her left ring finger.

“You’re always like this, Jonah. It would be so much easier to just get it over with.”

“I know,” the large man agreed.

“Do you?” Pale eyes stared dubiously at the stocky figure on their left.

“Sure I do. You know what happened with Lucy.”

His companion said nothing, bringing her hand up to her mouth and tugging at the nail, hard as it was to find much purchase on the nub that remained. They sat there in tense silence for a long time watching miniature hands reach out from the depths of the mist.

“Sorry,” Jonah apologized eventually. “I just – it’s my fault, Mary. There’s a right way to tell him that, so he can be angry with me then talk to you with a clear head.”

“He might not even be mad. Maybe he’ll say – that just means you’re perfect for each other, and go back to feeding the homeless or whatever.”

It was Jonah’s turn to give a hard look.

“He’s not a saint.”

“He sure acts like he is,” Mary scoffed.

“He really cares,” Jonah argued defensively.

“I never said he didn’t. I just think it must be exhausting being perfect all the time.”

Jonah indulged in his own vengeful silence for a while.

“Do you even like him?”

“I like his ass.”

“Mary, seriously.”

“I mean, he’s perfect. Perfect body, perfect personality. I fuck up and then he apologies. I just… it just sucks to be reminded every day how shit I am.”

Mary attacked the remains of her fingernail with renewed vigor.

“I didn’t want to be a cynic Jonah,” she confessed, speaking through her teeth. “I wanted to grow up and be a good person and for everyone to love me. But…”

“It’s a lot of pressure, isn’t it? Feels like whatever you do isn’t enough.”

“Exactly. See, you get it.”

Mary turned and gave him a wry smile, and Jonah’s breath caught. She really was beautiful, and Isaac really was a lucky son of a bitch to marry her – Jonah knew he would, despite this misstep on their part. When he listened to him talk about her, he knew they saw the same woman: cutting wit and shameless laughter, piercing words juxtaposing sweet tenderness. As if she saw you for who you really were and somehow still loved you. Shame flooded him as he looked at her, knowing that he was part of ruining something great for them both. He was supposed to know better.

“You’re going to be late,” he said abruptly, wanting to be alone. “I’ll talk with him after our shift, and then he’ll be all yours.”

Without waiting for a response, he stood and made his way up the stairs to the entrance of the church. He turned at the last second as he held the massive wooden door open, but he couldn’t make out anything through the fog.

***

“I can’t believe him,” a voice babbled in Isaac’s idiosyncratic baritone, manic. Jonah froze on the steps, just out of sight, sure that Isaac had overheard him and Mary just now.

“Shifting the food service to every other day just means the regulars will starve,” he exclaimed, and Jonah breathed a silent prayer of thanks for routine injustices before descending into the room. Isaac was in the middle of the dressing room preparing for their morning assignment, struggling to tighten the straps of a shoulder piece. A deacon was next to him changing into robes, and knowing better than to interrupt one of Isaac’s rants simply nodded silently in affirmation.

“I have to talk to the cardinal today after the meeting. The church wouldn’t allow this, it goes against everything we stand for. I also don’t see how the city is short on funds when the mayor just installed that ridiculous garden. I was getting complaints for months – oh, Jonah, thank goodness, help me out here.”

Jonah diligently went to his friend and investigated the ostentatious armor, finding that a buckle was straining against the final rung.

“You put on more muscle,” he remarked incredulously, wrestling the strap shut.

Isaac winced at the tightness, then grabbed a bracer and held it over his wrist.

“Not intentionally. It’s getting to be a real pain having to re-fit these things every year.”

Jonah shook his head, forcing the taut straps of the bracer shut across an oversized forearm.

“So what has our pious local government done this time?” The deacon, still half-undressed, shook his head feverishly in warning, but it was too late.

“He’s cutting our food budget,” Isaac huffed, pulling away from Jonah to pace back and forth across the tiny room.

“Just like last year – I don’t know what he told the cardinal but he told me that there was a budget crisis, so we can’t afford the herbs needed to treat syphilis. Well, guess what, now we have an epidemic on our hands, and he’s cutting food to three times a week. So we’re supposed to just let people rot?”

Isaac ran a hand through thick golden locks, visibly distressed, and in spite of the circumstances Jonah felt a swell of pride.

“I’ll have to bring this up at the council meeting tomorrow – they must not have heard about this yet, otherwise someone would have said something. Allen,” he looked at the deacon who was struggling with the final layer of his outfit, “you’ll be there, right? Can you put something together tonight? Please?”

The older man slumped visibly.

“Sure, Isaac. Happy to,” he meekly acquiesced.

“What can I do?” Jonah asked, not to be outdone.

Isaac gave him a winning smile.

“You and I are going to make our case to the top.”

***

They stood stiffly in the cathedral, grateful for the cool temperature bundled as they were in layers of cotton and steel, facing each other across once beautiful tiled floors long since tarnished from decades of oaken feet dragged across their faces. The nave was doubling as a meeting hall for the aristocrats, its pews with varnish long since faded replaced with plush upholstery brought downstairs from the cardinal’s office.

Dandy noblemen made their way to fill the room, their sickly sweet perfume almost eliciting a visible gag from Jonah, who had spent most of his twenty five years of life smelling sweat and farts rather than ambergris. He could make out Isaac stifling a laugh at his bulging eyes, and knew he would be teased relentlessly for this later – one bittersweet thing to look forward to before Jonah’s eventual confession.

The thought twisted his stomach, offering a distraction to the flamboyant retinue. He wondered if Isaac would cut him off like Lucy did. Would he ask for an assignment elsewhere, leaving Jonah to fend for himself among the silly royalty that frequented this city? Would he take Mary with him, depriving him of the only two friends he had made his whole life? A memory of silken black hair falling undone around bare shoulders flashed through his mind, and Jonah had a sudden fear that he would be ill.

“If it please the court, the Duke of Southguarden would begin the processions,” an unctuous voice rang out, followed by a grumbling consent from the crowd. The attendant respectfully bowed to the thin man at his side and stepped away, while the lanky noble adorned in dark green finery rose from his upholstery and drifted gracefully across the floor to the pew, tanned leather soles hardly appearing to touch the long faded artwork beneath them. Jonah noticed the man look towards the right side of the room,  where the cardinal was sitting, and nod.

“Gentlemen and gentlewomen of the court,” he began, taking the time to look each oligarch in the eye, “I have come today the bearer of terrible news.

“You are all familiar with our eastern neighbors. Philistine though they are, for a decade we have hoped to preach to them the gospel, and thus save them from fiery damnation. Such is our duty as followers of this holy church.”

The crowd murmured assent.

“To spread this word of God, as I’m sure this ever capable crowd is aware, requires an immense organization of church members – priests, pastors, volunteer missionaries from among the poorest of our society, sisters to support these holy men with the preparation of food and the cleaning of their sacred supplies. It was one of these excursions that was organized hardly two fortnights ago, led by none other than our most beloved father Jean-Paul. You will remember that he was the face of our multi-generational community kitchen for the last twenty years.”

Jonah risked a glance at Isaac and saw horror writ across his face.

“I have just received a report that his mission group was ambushed, invited to rest under false pretenses and the populace then forsaking the commandment of safe respite with ruthless predetermination. If any of the more generous-minded of you once believed in any basic decency of these savages, let this be the ultimate, irrefutable proof against it.

“I would be remiss not to celebrate Jean-Paul’s heroic effort to defend himself and those under his leadership. I was assured by the sole survivor that he fought valiantly – but every soul in this cathedral knows all too well that Jean-Paul was a man of peace. He was trained to wield scripture over a sword, gospel over force. He was not equipped with such righteous armament as we are, with soldiers such as these watching over us in case of grave circumstances.”

The reedy man motioned with a nod to the four paladin that stood as ceremonial guards in the chamber, and though Jonah strained not to meet their gaze he could feel their greedy stares piercing through him.

“I do not condone the indulgence nor the recreation of senseless violence,” the man continued. “But it is critical to our timely and I urge imminent response that I share two crucial details. First, no man nor woman was intentionally left alive – no prisoners of war, no hostages with which to bargain some unfair trade. Our sole survivor managed to escape among the chaos and make his way back to the city, and when we found him he was near dead from dehydration and exhaustion. Second, before, or perhaps after their death, each sister was… Forgive me, it is too terrible to be said aloud.”

He stood there silently for a long while, looking as if he were on the verge of tears.

“Simply said, it was a violation. Directly violating our cardinal sins – no, violating any decency that ought to be expected of a civilized society. This is the enemy that we have found ourselves pit against, and I know that I speak for us all when I say that they must be eliminated. For who is to stop such savagery from creeping westwards to seek the resources we have toiled for centuries to accumulate here? Are we, as stewards of this land, of this world, expected to allow such wretched evil to unleash itself upon the innocents we have sworn to protect?

“My proposal is a simple one. Markus Alabaster, our esteemed cardinal, I would ask that you donate the temporary usage of your retinue to make a strike on the city of Orengarde. I plan to make my case to the mayor and am hoping to subsidize these troops with more from the city’s guard. We would march east, and within two weeks reach the borders of the city and purge it. Thank you all for your consideration.”

With this, the verdant nobleman walked off the stage, and the crowd to this point struck silent exploded into an uproar. Some shouted words of damnation against the brutes, others crying for bloody vengeance. A few that knew Jean-Paul well shed open tears at the loss of their friend. The variety in responses regardless, the consensus was clear, and after long minutes of yelling and fist-pounding the cardinal walked to the pew, adorned in as flushed a garb as the faces he looked upon, and consented.

***

The next few hours were chaos. Isaac and Jonah rushed to organize their fellow paladins, and then fell into the agitated logistics of military transportation: horses, mules, food and water, medical aid, which of the clerics were the least likely to bolt at the first sign of danger, weapons – would they need a cannon or ballista, no there were no stone walls of the city – enchantments, staffs, scrolls, tomes that could be spared from the library, spare clothing in case of rain or snow, tents, wood and flint for fires, blankets to stave of the winter air, and so on.

Before Jonah knew it evening had fallen, and the conversation he was supposed to have with Isaac could not have felt more implausible then at this moment where they were both surrounded by dozens of other men, not to mention Isaac’s preoccupation with the sudden death of his old mentor. While the exhausted retinue milled about in the courtyard, waiting for further instruction, Jonah snuck off to the library, Mary having motioned for him to return after they had stared at each other with wide eyes as overzealous soldiers plucked spell scrolls off the shelves like candy.

“In here,” Mary hissed as Jonah poked his head into the hallway leading to the ransacked archives, motioning to a small room around the corner. They stuffed themselves within and shut the door, and Jonah immediately regretted not stopping by the baths to wash himself.

“What is happening?” Mary asked, breathlessly, eyes wild.

“Orengarde,” Jonah said stupidly, before extrapolating. “They killed the missionaries. Isaac’s boss.”

“Fuck.” Mary impulsively brought a middle finger to her lips, forgetting her determination to limit the damage to just one nail.

“That’s what they get for proselytizing all the damn time. So why are they sending you?”

“Clean up.”

Mary stared at him.

“What the hell does that mean?”

“The cardinal wants us to wipe them out. Revenge. In case they come west.”

“That makes no sense. Why the hell would they come west? They probably just want to be left the fuck alone. Lord knows what those freaks were doing to them without direct supervision.”

An image of Jean-Paul emerging from his sister’s bedroom surfaced from the vestiges of Jonah’s memories. He remembered being jealous of the towering man’s ring during the height of his aspirations to work for the diocese: burnished gold, the church’s color, with a massive  sparkling emerald. The man had looked quite frustrated with Jonah for disturbing them… That would have been right around the time –

“So are you going to go?”

“I have to,” Jonah replied, shocked at the suggestion. “I can’t disobey the cardinal’s direct orders.”

Mary gave him another long look, and Jonah squirmed under her gaze.

“I have no choice. Besides, Isaac is going.”

“There’s always a choice.” Mary crossed her arms and looked away, and Jonah realized that the conversation was done. He squeezed awkwardly around her and pushed open the door.

“I’ll talk with him. Isaac, I mean.”

“OK.” Her voice sounded hoarse.

“We should be back in a month.”

Suddenly she reached out a hand and gripped his wrist tight, her grip surprisingly painful given her size.

“Jonah – there’s something odd about this whole thing. Promise me you’ll both come back?”

Jonah looked into pale, glittering eyes, and put his other hand on hers. Her knuckles were cold.

“No matter what.”

Jan 14th, 500 p.d.

Jonah slept fitfully that night, the soldiers released to their homesteads for one last evening of relative comfort before marching the following morning. Mary’s voice thick with worry haunted him, and his dreams were filled with manifestations of the various ways he would inevitably fail her. He thought of a hundred ways for Isaac to die, and of how he could not prevent them – stabbings, lancings, arrows through the gap in his helmet, cannonballs, poison darts, trampling by horse or any large enough animal, surprise attack by beasts on the road, illness, syphilis (Jonah knew Isaac would never sleep with anyone other than Mary but it was on the rise), falling off the cliffs along the most direct road to Orengarde, being pushed off said cliff, maiming, torture, getting in a fight with the other soldiers (Isaac would probably struggle with the laisez-faire attitude of the lower classes) and getting hit in the temple, aneurysm, heart attack, heat stroke, frostbite, and so his mind wandered viciously. He lay in that liminal space between rest and awareness wishing that he could transport his soul into the body of another and escape this madness, until he was forced fully awake by a loud pounding on his door and made to drag himself in full armor to the entrance of the city.

The gates that led into the bitter wilderness beyond the stone walls that garrisoned Jonah most his life stood shorter than he remembered. Huge branches of rosemary rose nearly to the gates height, dwarfing the other foliage that crept in from the wilderness beyond. He had never actually left the city at any point – he was born in the church, lived in the crowded residential area his whole life, then moved back to the church once he had been formally apprenticed as a paladin. The last time he had really looked at these gates were many years ago when as a child he would sit on the steps of a bar that had long since shut down and watch expectantly for Lucy’s return. She never did come back.

Thankfully Isaac had finally appeared, and Jonah gratefully moved his pack around to make space for the massive man. He had come surely over prepared, strapping himself with a backup long sword, a short sword, three daggers attached haphazardly across his chest, and a massive lance whose heel drug unceremoniously along the ground. Jonah fell silently to his habit of cleaning his friend up – adjusting straps, repositioning weapons, rubbing at the most obvious stains on his friend’s neglected armor. Isaac stood there fidgeting all the while, scanning the horizon and huffing when he did not find what he was looking for.

“I haven’t seen Mary,” he said, finally, and Jonah cringed, grateful that his face was hidden while he moved the lance on Issac’s back up a few inches in its holdings.

“I ran into her yesterday at the library. I think she was held back helping the clerics prepare their books,” he lied. “They probably kept her later than they kept us last night.”

Isaac sighed deeply, shoulders dropping comically in the morning sunlight. Jonah, finishing his ministrations, moved to face his friend.

“She made me promise we would both come back,” he assured, putting a hand on Issac’s shoulder and looking into his friend’s worried eyes. Isaac was crestfallen.

“I feel like something has been wrong. I’ve hardly seen her the past couple of weeks.”

“Isaac… There’s something I need to talk to you about.” Jonah willed himself to confess his sins now, and relieve himself the torment of waiting for some perfect opportunity; willed that he could do what needed to be done in the moment, for once. Yet the thoughts of Isaac’s many potential demises resurfaced in his mind – how was he supposed to protect him if he ended their friendship now? Isaac would storm off in a fury and get himself killed before they even made it to the battlefield. Now was not the right time – soon, when he was somewhere safe.

“We have to talk to the cardinal before it’s too late. About the food.”

Isaac’s sunken face reanimated.

“The food! How could I forget? Yes, yes! Let’s go, before everyone leaves!” They both hurried away with hardly a glance from the others, their colleagues long since taught to be unfazed by Isaac’s sudden mood swings. The steps up to the church were grueling in full armor, and they were both sweating profusely by the time they made it to the cardinal’s room. Isaac rapped politely, learned enough dealing with church leadership to stay his excitement, and after a couple of long minutes the elderly cardinal Alabaster opened the door and invited them in. He motioned for them to sit, but they both refused, worried about ripping the fine velvet seating with their armor.

“Isaac,” he said with a nod, “and Jason, was it?”

“Jonah, sir.”

“Right. What can I do for you both? You’re both due to march out any minute now.”

“Yes, sir,” Isaac said, a little too quickly. “We wanted to make a request, while we were gone. With Jean-Paul’s departure I had been the one managing the community kitchen. I found out yesterday morning that the mayor plans to reduce the city’s subsidy, from a daily supply to only three times a week.”

The cardinal nodded slowly, causing Jonah to frown. He did not appear surprised at the news.

“Well, if I can be blunt, sir, it’s just not right. As you of course know it’s our duty to protect the most vulnerable, and having managed the kitchen for the past two months, we’re barely keeping up with demand as it is. Just one day less would be devastating – four days less…”

The cardinal held up a hand.

“Of course, Isaac. You are absolutely right, and very correct to bring this to my attention. It would be the height of hypocrisy to send you on a crusade against an existential threat to this city while turning a blind eye to the immediate needs of its inhabitants. I will take care of it.”

“Thank you sir,” Isaac gushed. “I asked Allen to put together a statement for the council meeting, but if you are taking care of it then I can tell him not to get in the way. The mayor built that garden last year and -”

“Thank you for taking initiative, Isaac,” the older man interrupted. “I will coordinate with Allen. Now go, before you both get left behind.”

“Yes sir!”

They jogged as best they could, more of a hurried walk with their armaments weighing them down, and made it back down to the city gates just as the rest of the military retinue was beginning their march.

“Thank you, Jonah,” Isaac whispered as they paraded down the road leading out of the city. “I don’t know what I would do without you.”

Jonah forced a smile.

“I’ve got your back, Isaac.”

***

They camped that first night on the side of the dirt road, one tenth of the way to their destination, already aching from the full day’s march. The more experienced soldiers from the city garrison, laughing at the young paladins, told them they were idiots for marching the first day in full steel, and so rather embarrassed they spent the evening peeling off their many layers and tying them down on donkeys.

Jonah had made it a point to steer clear of the stables most of his career, but the camp was already infused with the smell of equine waste. It didn’t help that the city troops were not particularly hygienic themselves, leaving their own feces lining the side of the road rather than digging holes like the paladins had been instructed.

Overwhelmed, and tired of cringing at Isaac’s over-earnest attempts to befriend the jaded militia, Jonah had to excuse himself from their company and spend his time in the darkness away from the camp. Not willing to walk very far, he found a patch of dead grass thirty meters away and collapsed, stretching his aching legs and shoulders in the cool evening air. Somewhat away from the pungent smell of the retinue, he could make out the familiar aroma of rosemary wafting down from somewhere upwind. That damn weed was everywhere, it seemed.

Laying on his back and staring at the mass of stars above him, something strange occurred to Jonah. It seemed as if the lights in the sky were bending and aligning themselves into a shape, but he couldn’t quite make out what it was.

He rubbed his eyes and looked again, but the stars had returned to normal. Jonah figured he must be hallucinating from sleep deprivation, and gradually fell asleep to the sounds of raucous laughter and snide jokes.

In his dreams, the slender aristocrat adorned in dark green livery from yesterday morning appeared, sitting on a leather couch in a well lit room that reminded him of the cardinal’s elaborate office. He did not appear to acknowledge Jonah’s presence, and was otherwise alone, his head braced casually against a hand, reading from a massive book on his lap. He turned a thin page with a reed-like finger and began to read aloud.

Jonah was a simple boy from Gath-hepher who knew little of right or wrong. His father was a prophet and had no time for a carefree son who had no interest in spreading the word of God. In fact, if anything, Jonah had an especial aversion to the relationship between prophet and deity, seeing how his father bent unquestioningly to the fickle will of his Lord. Eventually the older man passed and Jonah was surprised to experience, for the first time, the relief of a stable life. He worked for many years, married a woman as every young man then was obligated, and expected that he would soon begin a family of his own.

Yet on one summer eve, overjoyed and exhausted after his wife told him she had missed her cycle, he slept and had a vision from the Lord. We do not know what he saw, or how it was described to him, but he awoke early the next morning with an overwhelming certainty that he was to go to Ninevah and instruct them to repent for their wickedness, and that if they did not repent they will be smitten from the Earth. But what did Jonah care for the enemies of Israel? If they chose to anger God then they could suffer the consequences. Besides, far more importantly, he had no siblings nor surviving relatives, so how could he leave his pregnant wife to fend for herself in the city, given that long travels were no place for an expectant mother?

So he prayed that his vision was merely a nightmare or hallucination driven by his memories of his father and went about his life. Yet on the eve of his daughter’s birth neither mother nor child survived and so Jonah knew such was the call of God.

How could a man not be bitter at the death of his family? At the absurdity that both father and son must share the same fate, when any other able bodied servant would do just as well? So Jonah more out of spite than fear went to the docks in Joppa and purchased passage to Tarshish on a trade boat, in the opposite direction of his assignment.

The crew on the boat was unfriendly but not inhumane, and he spent his time with little human interaction as passenger aboard the merchant vessel. After three days it became clear to the crew that the containers below deck that were supposed to contain food for the last legs of their journey were filled instead with textiles. With twenty crew and ten passengers, the remaining food would hardly last a day, much less the week remaining needed to reach Tarshish. So the captain gathered his crew and his passengers and told all aboard they must draw lots, and those with the shortest stick would be killed and eaten, and Jonah drew the short stick and knew this was his punishment. Could they have turned and docked along any of the numerous ports to resupply? Certainly. Such was the will of the Lord.

Not able to bear the thought of his own body consumed by others, Jonah in a fit of madness, or perhaps rationality, flung himself from the docks and expected to drown. So the text claims, though surely this could not be, he was swallowed by a fish and trapped below the water for three days and three nights. Much more likely he washed up along some distant shore half-dead, miraculous but not impossible, or picked up days later by some chance vessel and delivered delirious to the nearest coast.

Regardless, Jonah survived, and finally consented to his holy mission. However long it took he made his way to Ninevah and began to preach to passerbys on the street.

Hear my tale, we can imagine he cried. I have heard the will of God and refuted it, and for rejecting my duty I endured travesties no human should.

Surely he was one of many madmen that lined the populous streets of Ninevah, and just as surely was he disregarded. Who can say if it was months or years, but eventually Jonah realized that the city would remain as it was, and he despaired. What was the point of his pathetic life, then – of all his loss and misery? Would he a true believer perish while a city of heathens prospered?

So he left the city with the fervor for life long since burnt out of him and he lay upon a hill side facing towards Ninevah and waited to die, sleeping beneath the shade of a large fruiting tree. He awoke and motivated by great hunger reached for the sole fruit hanging heavy on a branch, yet he saw that the flesh was worm-ridden, and beneath it and around him lay the bodies of the vermin that had fallen and felled themselves on the arid ground.

So Jonah lay there dying, pondering the mass of wriggling invertebrates, and thought: am I the worm? Do I struggle vehemently just to die beneath the tree that sustains me?

The man robed in green smirked.

But Jonah was wrong, for he was not the worm, but rather the gourd.

Jan 19th, 500 p.d.

The five days of travel were taking a toll on the green paladins, all of them young and frankly untrained for the march. Even Isaac’s ruddy disposition, which had served a powerful motivator for the increasingly sleep deprived Jonah, had begun to fade, beaten down as much by exhaustion as incessant haranguing from the jealous soldiers.

“Isaac,” Jonah prompted, head pounding from after yet another turbulent night. “I had a strange dream.”

Isaac glanced at his friend and pursed his lips.

“Have you been having nightmares as well? You look terrible,” he responded, scrutinizing Jonah’s gaunt face and sunken eyes.

“I don’t know. It was about the man from the noble’s meeting. He was… no, nevermind. It was just a dream.”

Isaac nodded..

“You’re worried about what we’re doing. If it’s right.”

Jonah almost laughed. He had been so preoccupied with his bizarre vision and Isaac’s survival that he had barely spent any time pondering the morality of their crusade.

“Right,” he replied, not wanting to admit where his mind had been.

“Well, I’ve thought a lot about it the past few days,” Isaac confessed. “Jean-Paul was a gentle and loving man. If these people really did kill him in cold blood, then they are a danger. Better those that can deal with them do so, before it becomes the problem of those that can not.”

Jonah was taken aback.

“What if… what if they didn’t do it? Isn’t it a little too convenient a story?”

Isaac’s eyebrows furrowed.

“The cardinal isn’t stupid,” he said hotly. “He would have considered all possibilities, and made the call that resulted in the least amount of human suffering.”

“Well, as far as we can tell the cardinal only heard what the duke told him. What if the duke was lying?”

“He wouldn’t do that in a church.”

“Isaac,” Jonah chided, exasperated, “you wouldn’t do that, but couldn’t someone else?”

“Look, the cardinal communes directly with higher powers. Our duty as his servants is to follow orders, not question them.”

With that Isaac stormed off, leaving Jonah pacing dumbfounded behind him. The armament proceeded along the narrow ridge of the cliff side among the midpoint, sheer face laden with shale and granite. A thought of flinging himself off the side briefly flitted through his mind, but was quickly suppressed with visions of a slow demise lying lacerated among the rocks below. So, with no other option, Jonah labored on.

Jan 23rd, 500 p.d.

They set eyes upon the town on the eve of the tenth day of marching. Jonah’s feet were covered in blisters and his muscles ached from overuse, so it was a relief to finally gaze down upon the wooden gates of Odengarde. He was not sure what he had been expecting, but was surprised at the constitution of the structure – it was difficult to tell for sure from a distance but seemed that nine or ten foot tall wooden beams had been meticulously glued together with some sort of cement or industrial adhesive, spread diligently around a circumference of a thousand or so meters. Umber buildings stood sturdy within their shroud, curving in an elaborate architecture, with moss-laden roofs insulating them against the cool winter air. Squinting, he could make out woven sheep’s wool hung openly along windowsills, and vibrant textiles blanketing the ground near the center of town.

One of the gruff, balding city guards Jonah had learned called himself Tarnish spat on the ground.

“Peasants,” he grumbled.

A group of older men murmured assent, although Jonah noticed Isaac fidgeting silently besides them. The soldiers got to work setting up camp for the night, with orders from their commander to prepare for an early morning siege. Donkeys were relieved of their burdens though sporting deep red sores from clumsy bindings during the long journey, leather sleeping pads lined with dirt-stained cotton were rolled unceremoniously along dirt road and gravel roadside, and cold hard-tack was passed mutely among frigid fingers.

Jonah could not keep his eyes off the swarthy village, eyes registering movement in the evening twilight – small figures chasing each other around alleyways, a large cauldron of something carried to the center of the town and left there, painted branches brought from houses to decorate the makeshift city center. Then, a large fire lit and what seemed the whole town gathering together, ladling something out of the cauldron, men and women pulling out instruments that Jonah could not hear but imagined hearing, tiny figures animated like motes of dust prancing about and holding each other, until many hours later the last embers died and only the crescent moon illuminated the exhausted faces of the crusaders as they stared from their vantage point with spite.

He had never felt so strange in his life, sat as he was insomnolent and hypothermic and apart, so apart from the joviality he had just witnessed. Would that he could switch places with any of the sable figurines now asleep one night more, like dolls in a dollhouse, some make believe utopia impossibly better than its reflection. Would he also sing and dance and be merry? Could he? Was there some version of him, some orthogonal apparition that diverged at that moment, where father and mother survived, where Lucy returned, or perhaps never left at all? Where he was a man who was not so coward as to rely on his only friend to decide the moral authority for them both?

“Isaac,” he whispered. He knew he was awake from the incessant, obsessive shuffling to his right. The golden haired mountain besides him merely grunted.

“Mary and I slept together.”

The shuffling stopped, and for a long, long time the air hung hollow, broken only by an uncomfortable breeze occasionally flowing through the camp. Jonah, in disbelief at what he had just said, sat poised for Isaac’s reaction, adrenaline coursing through constricting veins. All senses amplified to superhuman levels, he recognized a familiar odor from upwind, and through the pale moonlight made out one lone wiry rosemary bush ten meters up the mountainside. It arched wild and desperate, thin branches almost bereft of leaves, and Jonah in nigh delirium imagined himself poised in its shape.

So transfixed was he that he did not notice the fist until it struck him across the cheek, laying him on his stomach.

“Bastard,” Isaac muttered, seemingly to himself.

Jonah lay there in his shame.

“It’s my fault.”

“Damn you.”

“We were drinking”

“Damn you.”

“It was late.”
“Damn you to hell.”

“It was a mistake.”

Silence, then, “was it?”

“Of course it was,” Jonah murmured into the dirt.

“I never understood her,” Isaac said quietly, suddenly pensive. “You did, though. You both speak the same language.”

“I don’t know what you’re talking about.”

“Fuck you. You know exactly what I’m talking about.”

Jonah lay there, immobile as the granite cliffs around him, because he did.

“I didn’t want this. Isaac, you’re-”

“Open your mouth one more time and I swear on your dead parents’ graves I’ll rip your head off.”

Jonah shut his mouth, and after an hour of nothing the two fell asleep.

***

He awoke to shouting, and he struggled to his feet in the dawn light, neck aching from laying askew on the hard ground. Isaac was in the center of camp with the commander, face red with fury.

“I won’t stand for this,” he roared, causing stirs among the rest of the encampment. A man not from the retinue was on the ground next to him, presumably some scout from Orengarde, bleeding from a blunt wound across his temple. Jonah saw that he was not quite dead yet, evidenced by slow breaths, but his eyes while open were unfocused and his mouth hung almost comically ajar.

“You knew what we were getting into, kid,” the commander replied, irritated rather than indignant.

“I thought…” Isaac faltered. “I thought it was the right thing to do.”

The commander snorted derisively.

“We don’t have time for this. Put your armor on, soldier.”

“No.” Isaac’s voice did not quaver this time.

Cruel laughter erupted from their side, and the steadily growing crowd turned to see Tarnish saunter from his crew into the center of the circle.

“Seems like our resident crybaby-”

Jonah saw the flash of steel but was standing too far away to stop Isaac’s hand. The guard’s head flew off his neck and tumbled to the ground, face frozen in one last sneer. Jonah began to run, but as Isaac was focused on the consequence of his impulsive vengeance, the commander raised a saber of his own and struck Isaac in the stomach. Isaac fell in a heap, clutching at the gut wound, and just as Isaac reached them the commander finished the job with a swift jab to his throat. He leveled the blade against Jonah as a warning, but the paladin ignored him, falling to his knees and clutching at Isaac’s body.

“No, Isaac, please.” he begged, desperately running through the forms for healing magic he had always been terrible at.

“Cleric. A cleric,” he shouted, but as he looked around desperately none of the armament dared move.

“Enough,” the commander said with finality. “The lot of you, prepare yourselves.” He motioned to the soldiers, who shaken out of their reverie scrambled to follow orders.

“Pull yourself together paladin,” he said, looking down at Jonah. “If you’re not there at the charge, I’ll finish you off myself.” Then, stepping over the injured foreigner, he walked off.

Jonah barely registered the threat, frantically pressing against the gouged skin beneath his friend’s jaw. Try though as he might, the neck wound was a deadly, practiced strike, clean through the artery, and blood flowed unabated through Jonah’s shaking fingers.

“Please, no,” Jonah begged. “I still need to fix this. We have to go back and you have to marry Mary and – please… don’t leave me too.”

Isaac aspirated blood one last time, pink foam dripping down his cheek, and then he was still. Jonah’s tears blurred his vision, too busy clutching at Isaac’s body to wipe at his face, and the wet astigmatism began to skew unnaturally. His compromised vision swirled and rotated, and he looked around in horror, realizing that he could not see. He stumbled to his feet, nearly tripping over the two bodies in front of him, and staggered as if drunk around the camp. Then, just as suddenly as it began, it ended, and his vision stabilized. He wiped at his face, rubbing blood across his face, and blinking furiously saw that he was standing in front of the solitary growth of rosemary he had noticed the evening before. The branches that just that evening had stood frail and sickly now burst with new emerald growth, and Jonah finally understood.

So he walked mutely back to the empty camp and adorned himself with the church’s armor as golden as its railings, strapped his longsword across his back, and following the commander walked to the front lines to join the assault.

***

What is it to take a life? A natural thing, perhaps, one soul in exchange for another, all fair in the eyes of an indifferent God that wishes pretty insects into existence and demands they dance for him. So Jonah mused with the zealous troops as they stood just outside the range of arrow fire and considered the stalwart gates of the city, starving creatures salivating on the eve of a feast.

What choice is there but to fulfill his will?

Jonah peered upwards, gray sunlight shining through an overcast sky, and looked at the blurry outlines of the village’s defenders. He imagined they stared back with a grim resolution, hoisting weapons of their own, waiting, and that in their insufferable purgatory they prayed.

The commander raised an arm, gauntlet of silver and maroon reflecting the dull light of the morning, and the men around him roared and charged. A response echoed through the ranks of the men and women along the ridges of the wooden walls and they fired the first cloud of arrows. The projectiles struck true and soldiers collapsed to the floor in cries of pain, barbed arrows protruding from gaps in their armor.

Jonah and the retinue sprinted onwards, leaving the unlucky men to their fate, and suffered two more such volleys before reaching the perimeter of the town. They huddled underneath their shields as arrowheads and rocks rained down upon them from on high, biding time. Finally, a wheezing pot-bellied man emerged from the depths of the huddled men and began to move his shaking fingers in a pattern, whispering furiously to himself. A rogue arrow snuck between a gap in the shields held overhead and struck him in the thigh just as he neared completion, and as he cried out, a massive wall of flame fell from the sky and incinerated him and the ten nearest soldiers.

Despite a cheer that rose through the crowd above him, the siege magic had done as intended, evaporating enough of the wall to allow soldiers to begin pouring through. They struck at the unarmored villagers ruthlessly, the reinforced metal of the armament castrating the lethality of makeshift spears. Another ball of flame erupted in the center of the opening, blowing men away like leaves and setting the dry wood of the breached wall ablaze. Jonah traced the arc of embers to a tall woman ducking around the corner of one of the buildings. He pushed through screaming men and made his way to her, feeling arrows hit his armor but failing to pierce it. Just as he turned the corner an iron spearhead flashed out from below and jabbed into the open space along his inner thigh, piercing through the muscle. He cried out in pain and instinctively flailed his sword arm, and only when it was too late did he realize he had cut into the thin body of a teenager. The reedy boy couldn’t have been more than sixteen, and he stared at the sword pushing through his lung in disbelief.

Blood began to fill his lungs and he started coughing, saliva mixing with crimson life force to form a raspberry paste that trickled viscous down his cheek, and it reminded Jonah so much of Isaac’s death that he pulled his sword out and impulsively swung again. The sword cut across the boy’s rib cage, not deep enough to kill, and he fell to the floor choking. Jonah fell backwards, mage forgotten, and stared at his victim in horror. He was clawing at the dirt in front of him, fingers attempting to find some purchase or perhaps some answer in the coarse ground, and Jonah watched and saw how his bloody fingernails now digging through ferrous mud had been chewed down to nubs.

“No,” he breathed. “No.” And he crawled to the boy disregarding the agony in his leg and put his hands on his chest and prayed more earnestly than he ever had before. He prayed not for Isaac’s rebirth, not for Mary’s love, not even for Lucy’s return – but that whatever monstrous deity that governed this hell grant this child just one puny shred of mercy. He felt an uncomfortable heat course through his arms and his eyes scrunched shut in supplication flew open but the wounds on the boy’s chest remained and in addition now black scorch marks that matched the shape of his palms lay branded upon his pale skin and the boy lay still and so Jonah cradled the body in his arms and wept.

***

The battle continued for another hour or so, the shouts and screams of the skirmish gradually decaying to the occasional clash of weapons, or the rough grunt of someone impaled by a blade or javelin. Jonah lay the whole while leaning against a wall with the child limp in his arms, willing anyone – villager, commander, stray dog –  to chance upon him and end his unholy existence once and for all. But no one came, until the bloodbath had ended and the surviving watchmen patrolling the carnage found him bleeding and called for the only remaining cleric.

This one Jonah recognized as one of the newer recruits, a younger man that he recognized from Isaac’s circle of earnest do-gooders. He smiled in a grim but friendly way, and as if he thought it perfectly reasonable that he cradled the body of an enemy, gently tugged at his hands so that he relaxed his grip and pulled the corpse to the side. His body humming with light, he placed two hands on Jonah’s leg who watched in wonder as the pain in his thigh began to subside. On the verge of passing out just a minute ago, he now felt unnaturally energetic and vigorous, and with that vigor he channeled a mutinous death glare at the novice healer. The new recruit politely ignored him, and when he was done got up and hurried in the direction of more shouting from the scouts.

Jonah, filled suddenly with purpose, tried the door of the house he was leaning against and found that it was unlocked. He opened the entryway and made his way into the living space, and inside it found a simple painting on a makeshift canvas, crushed berries and horse-hair brush used to paint figures on a light papyrus. On it was a carefully detailed portrait of the boy outside, an almost sallow skin and too-big eyes covered in ragged hair and a toothy smile. He had the grace to stumble outside before allowing himself to be sick on the red ground by the door.

Heaving and sweating, he made his way back into the house and after some rummaging found what he was hoping for in a small room on the bottom floor – a simple spade with an oaken handle. As he walked past the painting in the living area, he picked up the horse hair brush and not able to bear the thought of the memento being destroyed pocketed it. Then he stepped around the mess he made by the entrance and began to dig. Once the hole was deep enough he carried the boy’s body to its crude grave and gently placed him at the bottom. Then, picking up his longsword from where it lay on the ground, stained brown with desiccated blood, he considered the ornate hilt crafted of precious metals into the shape of a cross and snapped it off across his knee. He took the shaft of the broken blade and stabbed it into the dirt and walked away.

In the center of the town atop once beautiful textiles, sewn with flowers now charred and muddied, a handful of the soldiers had restarted the fire that had been used the night before and were huddling around it. Jonah looked at the walls of the city smouldering with toxic fumes of the cement vaporized into a black gas, at houses with woolen drapings along windowsills that had caught fire leading eager flames into a sea of furnishments now tinder, upon the blue faces of the men he had known since he was a teenager staring dumbly at survivors quivering like dead leaves aching to be blown away in a windstorm, and wondered if it was enough.

The commander emerged from a nearby cottage, wiping fresh blood off his sword with a leather skirt he had pilfered, and moved to stand in the clearing with the rest of the men. 

“I didn’t see you much,” he said simply to Jonah, holding the stolen garment over the fire and then flinging it, alight, into the open door of the building.

Jonah said nothing, considering the graying man who was miraculously uninjured while he inspected his blade in front of the fire. Out of the corner of his eye he noticed a figure crawling along the roof of the pillaged house.

“Not sure I understood those of your… profession,” he continued. “I always figured you were little more than decor. Fancy baubles for the rich to gawk at while they said their pretty words. Guess I was right.”

The slender figure above him stopped along the rim of the roof, and Jonah recognized her as the mage he had run after this morning. In her hands was a small egg-shaped object, and with a quick movement of practiced fingers she produced a flame and lit a small strand that hung from the peak. The commander, having said his piece, had sheathed his sword and was beginning to turn away, clearing his throat as if preparing to organize the remaining soldiers.

“Wait,” Jonah said, catching the officer’s attention. “You’ll need this more than I will.”

He took the man’s gauntlet in one hand and maneuvered him between himself and the mage, and with his other hand pushed the severed hilt of his blade into the man’s palm. As the graying officer opened his mouth for another cruel retort, the mage tossed the object into the clearing and it exploded, sending iron shrapnel through the survivors. The commander fell, one particularly large chunk of iron having embedded itself a few inches into the back of his skull, and Jonah, unharmed, stood watching blood pool on the floor while shouting erupted around him. Crossbow bolts flew into the air and despite her attempt to scramble away one well placed shot pierced the mage through the back of the head and she fell limp and tumbled off the roof.

Jonah inhaled deeply. A familiar odor had started to fill the air.

February 2nd, 500 p.d.

When the skeleton crew returned to their camp after the battle, they were shocked to find Isaac laying as he had when they left him, asleep but markedly more alive than he had been earlier that day. His wounds had been sealed shut with hardly a scar to remember them by, and he breathed steadily in his rest, unlike the Orengardian scout who lay unblinking at his side. When Jonah picked him up to dump him off the mountainside he noticed that the commander must have finished him off as he was walking away – he had a hole in his neck identical to the one that killed Isaac. The young cleric that healed Jonah earlier had prostrated himself immediately upon seeing Isaac alive and would only move an hour later to help him move the miracle incarnate onto a makeshift stretcher and down the opposite side of the mountain.

Jonah for his part refused to take a break from bearing his friend’s body, compromising only to receive help from a rotating array of soldiers as they trekked the ten-day journey back to the city. Though he willed each new night to be their reconciliation, Isaac never awoke from his slumber. So Jonah spent each evening doting on his revivified friend, turning Isaac methodically to prevent sores from forming, swapping out his clothes and dumping bowel movements, and bundling him in blankets near the fire so he would not lose an extremity to frostbite. Since he was not awake to eat Jonah had to mash hard biscuits with water and spoon feed the slurry into an uncooperative mouth.

When complaints percolated through the evening air from the exhausted guards he would walk over to them and provoke a fight, beating them mercilessly so that by their return the retinue was rendered totally mute in terror. Only the cleric dared speak, under Jonah’s orders, to anoint Isaac each night before what appeared to the bewildered army as some strange aromatherapy applied to the sleeping giant using dried rosemary Jonah would collect obsessively during their food breaks each day.

Though none would believe it, Jonah for all his intention had no more insight beyond what he was granted the morning of the siege. He had no more visions nor losses of sight, and his nightmares were filled with the hands of the boy he murdered rather than elites adorned in arboreal garb. All he knew was that the herb he was forcing into his pockets each day was somehow responsible for Isaac’s revival, and so perhaps was useful to his eventual recovery as well. Though Jonah began to doubt even this as no improvements arrived in spite of his toils.

Jonah awoke on the final day of their excursion feeling completely empty, with a conviction that he had died just like Isaac had but his body instead of left vacant was filled with the soul of someone else. He could not bring himself to care about anything beyond Isaac’s immediate well being. The mutinous stares of his comrades stirred no anxiety nor regret in his heart, just as pockets bursting with decaying foliage resulting in no embarrassment. So it was that Jonah breached the city walls and could only watch with dead eyes as Mary ran past him to Isaac’s body and begged loudly in front of the whole town his forgiveness for her infidelity.

He was spirited away to various meetings after that, interviews with more officers and church officials that demanded an understanding of how so few of their number had returned. Jonah dully told the events of the battle a dozen times, only leaving out the parts he played in the death of the child and of the commander. Either through some miracle of trauma or perhaps a deeper hatred in the hearts of the survivors for the callous commander than the psychotic paladin, no punishment was arranged for Jonah’s insubordination.

Instead the church quickly arranged lavish celebrations, and in the evening of their arrival a great feast was thrown to celebrate the destruction of their eastern foe. Chickens and goats were slaughtered and stuffed with preserved apples and sage, berries that were canned five months ago were boiled down into viscous reductions, huge caskets of aged wine were rolled from beneath the cellars of the cathedral and shared amongst the populace not for communion but for revelry. Minstrels were summoned by the mayor to entertain the crowds, sorcerors that would never have been openly tolerated by the church on another day were allowed to launch fiery displays of magic, and sly brothel owners spirited away the drunkest of the crowd into alleyways with promises of distracted guards and discount prices.

Throughout the festivities Jonah was seated with the other soldiers at the head of a giant table and brought endless indulgences. Meat and alcohol and expensive sweets all presented before him on priceless china and in crystal goblets. Averse to any sort of food, much less insulting hedonism, Jonah just sat there sullenly and absently twirled one of the iridescent drinking glasses in his hand, pondering how the light of the torches and candles bent at sharp angles in the crystalline visage.

Finally, as the clock neared midnight, the opportunity he had been waiting for presented itself. The cardinal sat unattended by his usual retinue drinking from gilded chalice, altar boys and priests finally abandoning the celebrations for an early night. Jonah pushed his chair back and made his way towards the decrepit figure, seating himself without permission on a stool to his left.

The cardinal turned to look at him, squinting.

“Jensen, right?”

Jonah just stared at the elderly man, not bothering to correct him.

“Terribly sorry to hear about your friend,” he continued. “It is a small consolation, but you would be pleased to hear that the mayor has agreed to allocate an additional ten percent to the kitchen’s food – ”

“Help him,” Jonah interrupted.

“Uhm, I’m sorry?”

“Help him. Have your pastors do a ceremony. Pray the rosary. Sacrifice a goat, for all I care. I want you to make him normal again.”

The cardinal appraised the paladin, then took a long sip of his wine.

“Of course. We will do everything in our power – within reason, you understand.”

Jonah stared blankly at liver spotted cheeks.

“With the reduction in staff, it will be quite challenging maintaining normal operations. Many of the clerics that left with you had a number of administrative duties. Not to mention we will need to re-staff the missing paladins…”

“If I do your grunt work, you’ll heal him?”

Yellow teeth emerged from a crooked smile.

“Well when you put it like that, it sounds rather quid pro quo. But, if you prefer.” 

“Fine.”

“In that case, there is someone you must meet.” He motioned with his hand and one of the young servers hurried over, a trundle of cups in his arms. He whispered something in his ear and the boy bustled off. Jonah and the cardinal sat in silence for a few minutes, listening to musicians repeat their exhausted repertoire for the fifth time, until a portly man emerged from the crowd and joined them at the head of the long table. With a shock Jonah recognized him as the mayor.

“Pleasure,” he smiled, and reached out a smooth hand to Jonah, who was surprised by the firm handshake. He wore an exquisitely tailored black suit and maroon bowtie, and on the hand that he offered to Jonah he sported a beautiful golden ring with a massive emerald.

“Alabaster,” he nodded to the cardinal, who smiled mischievously back.

“Louis, this is your new contact for all duties regarding the church.”

“Ah,” the stranger looked Jonah up and down. “We had discussed the other one…”

“Invalid, unfortunately.”

“Right. Well, pleasure to meet you…?”

“Jonah.”

It was only for a second, but Jonah noticed a flash of surprise across the man’s face. The bureaucrat, not missing a beat, sat and began to fill Jonah in with the rough schedule of the obligations he would have for a city. Over his shoulder Jonah could make out children in the courtyard playing with wooden dolls in the flickering torchlight.

April 5th, 503 p.d.

Jonah stood in the doorway, apprehensive. When he heard the news he had dropped everything and went to the house, but now that he was here he wasn’t sure whether he would offer congratulations or condolences. Just as he decided he would be unwelcome, the door opened, and Mary’s haggard figure emerged into the moonlight.

“Jonah. It’s good to see you,” she breathed, giving him a small smile. Jonah could not help but think that she looked awful. Her eyes were sunken, her face gaunt, and her nails once somewhat presentable now were raw, bloody stumps. Jonah imagined them grasping at mud.

“I heard from Markus just now. That you and Isaac are to be wed.” Her face fell.

“Yeah. In three days,” she said quietly, bringing her left ring finger to her mouth.

“I…” Jonah started, but found that words failed him.

Mary looked over his shoulder, and seeing evening-goers milling around the neighborhood, motioned for him to come inside.

“Come in, I’ll make tea or something.”

He followed her inside and shut the door behind him, and taking off his recently cobbled boots trailed behind her into the kitchen. He raised his hands in an offer to assist in some way, but she motioned for him to sit and so he sat and watched her drift around the small room. Letting himself stare under the pretense of concern, he could see pieces of his memory of her remained true, in the way she balanced on one set of toes to reach for cups on the cupboard, and the restless twirling of her hair while she waited for the kettle to boil. Feelings long suppressed stirred rebelliously in his stomach, but as he had with many other errant emotions the past few years, he shoved them away for later

“You look good,” she said finally, gently placing a single cup of chamomile tea in front of Jonah. “You never used to dress this well.”

“I wouldn’t if I didn’t have to,” he admitted, bringing the beverage to his lips. It was understeeped – some things had not changed, perhaps.

“Now part of my job is to look pretty,” he continued, after taking a big, conspicuous swig.

“Must be nice,” she said off handedly, with a glance at the hallway.

“He’s…?”

“Just in the other room. Same, as always.”

Jonah nodded, a tiny flurry of hope crushed. A familiar feeling, recently.

“I’m sorry I haven’t been visiting as much. Work has been…” Jonah couldn’t look at the woman across from him.

Mary snorted. “I wouldn’t come if I were you, either. It’s fucking depressing.”

Jonah nearly spurted his tea all over her. He coughed, then laughed, a little too hard. Mary followed suit, and for a brief moment they were teenagers again.

“I really hoped something would change that first year,” Jonah admitted, candidly, after he had calmed down. “After that… I don’t know. It feels like Markus has been stringing me along this whole time. First it was those prayer books, then those visiting clerics he was recommended, then the archived scrolls. Now, well, this.”

“He’s taking advantage of you,” Mary said bluntly.

“I know,” Jonah conceded.

“Do you?”

Jonah smiled. “Yeah. You’re right, like you always are.”

Mary sniffed, feigning indignation.

“I was OK with it. As long as it got us Isaac back, right? I would have done anything. Would do anything. This, though…”

“I don’t know what I’m going to do,” Mary whispered, and the hoarseness of her voice tugged at Jonah’s heart.

“If it worked… would you be happy?”

Mary shook her head silently.

“I don’t know. It’s been so long. Kind of hard to keep the romance alive when you’ve wiped his ass twice a day for three years, too,” she said with a quiet laugh.

“What if we left? Packed our things and just ran. We could take a horse and make it to the port in a week,” Jonah blurted.

Mary looked at him, and for one beautiful second Jonah thought she would say yes.

“Jonah… It’s not that I don’t want to.”

“But,” he continued for her, willing against all odds to keep his composure.

“I just don’t think I could live with myself. It all feels kind of like my fault, you know? I do this terrible thing to him and then avoid him for two weeks and then he’s whisked away on this suicide mission and now he’s a fucking vegetable.”

Though he could not admit it aloud, he knew that deep down he felt the same way. Especially since he was the one that brought him back.

“You were right,” Jonah said, eyes on the mug in front of him. “I should have just told him that night. It’s all my fault.”

“Jonah,” she said with an exasperated smile. “Fuck off.”

She took his hand in hers and looked at him. He stared back, transfixed.

“Let’s just agree it’s both our fault, OK? You need the priest and the Book to read scripture, you know?”

“You’re the Book.”

Mary grinned at him. “Don’t push it.”

They held on to each other’s hands for a bit longer, until a groan from the living room caused them both to jump in their seats and instinctively pull away from each other.

“Shit,” Mary looked up at the ceiling of the small room and sighed.

“Should we…”

“No, no, he just does that sometimes.”

They sat there, both trying not to look at the other, while another inhuman moan echoed through the house.

“Mary, what do you think you’d be, if you had a different life from this one?” Jonah imagined Lucy running down a hallway much like the one in this house all those years ago.

She stared wistfully out a small window across from her. “When I was a girl I thought I’d love to be a princess, destined to live my life in excess. That was before I found out about all of the arranged marriages and politics and popping out an endless stream of babies. Then, as I grew up, I thought I wanted to be a famous artist, or poet, or something. I had learned how good it felt for people to like me, but I didn’t learn until later what it felt like when people did not. And that fame was just an amplification of those things.

“So, when I got old enough that it mattered how well I did in school I thought I wanted to be a scholar. To challenge myself intellectually every day, to prove to this shithole world that I’m the smartest thing it had ever seen. That’s why I started working as a scribe in the library – I wanted to work somewhere where I was surrounded by knowledge. Then I met you and Isaac, and for just a little while I thought that being swept into a simple life with a hot husband wouldn’t be so bad.

“But, as you know, the feeling didn’t last. Me dating Isaac was like a man dying of dehydration dating a mermaid. Eventually, all I could think was – ‘Damn, this guy is literally the exact opposite of me’. He would tell me about all of the gifts his coworkers would give him every week, meanwhile I was struggling to get the priests to look me in the eyes. He would spend all his free time volunteering to help the needy, but I was crying in my room about how I didn’t have any female friends my age. We would fuck and then he’d jump out of bed for his second or third workout of the day, while I was so burnt out I just wanted to sleep for eleven hours every night.

“It is just so god damn exhausting to be comparing yourself against that every day. Then, when he came back basically dead, but worse because now my full time job is keeping this comatose meat sack somehow clinging to the dredges of life, I learned that scholarly aspirations don’t mean shit when the church that runs this city tries to make a saint out of you.

“So, what do I think I would be, Jonah? Someone else somewhere else. Anything is better than this.”

Jonah looked on in horror as two thin lines of tears ran down her face, twinkling in the lamplight like the crystal goblet he drank wine from the night of his return, with light bending and reflecting and twisting over itself but in the chaos of its confusion, or perhaps because of it, creating something awesome. He thought of the body of the boy contorted in an unnatural angle at the bottom of the ditch and of the way he had sunk his torn fingers into the flesh of the earth as if demanding some answer for the injustice of it all from the indifferent surface of a planet that had not the mechanisms nor the will for understanding his suffering but still he picked away at it hoping that if he dug deep enough an answer would emerge and that is what Jonah had done is help him find that answer deeper deeper deeper into the cold ground.

“Sorry.” Mary wiped at the tears with a sleeve, sniffling. “I’ll be fine. It’s just hard right now.”

But Jonah knew that she was lying.

***

After the tenor of Mary’s repeated insistences that she would be okay turned from grateful to irritated, Jonah asked to see his old friend. Mary led him around the corner into an open room with a large window stretching out into the street. Isaac lay propped up on a bed of pillows facing the window, eyes open but looking at nothing, and mouth hung oddly ajar. He was a fraction of his weight at his prime, now looking disturbingly emaciated. Mary took a handkerchief and wiped at the line of drool on his chin, then excused herself to finish tending to some housework.

Jonah sat on a stool and stared out the window with Isaac for a long time, watching normal people walk food and children and themselves back and forth through the twilight. Occasionally he would hear the sound of something falling or breaking, quickly followed by an audible curse, and Jonah would not be able to control a smile.

“Mary as a housewife, huh?” he said to Isaac conversationally, as if he was in on the joke.

Isaac said nothing, maintaining a dull gaze somewhere around the edge of the windowsill.

“Funny that she ended up here while I’m the one teaching,” he continued. “I’m really bad at it, actually. All of the new paladins hate me. We’ve had four dropouts already – any more and we won’t have enough to man the noble’s meetings. The clerics are all sick of repeating themselves to me too, I know that they’ve all complained to Markus. Little do they know that while at least I am trying, he doesn’t give a real shit at all.

“I sit in meetings on the mayor’s council once a week, and they serve us expensive liquor while he entertains dignitaries, missionaries, entertainers and merchants. He knows his way around people, that’s for sure. More often than not they leave having made some investment in the city. That’s how he got that garden you were complaining about. Before the battle. Some famous florist gifted him a bundle of tulip bulbs, and he sweet talked a traveling carpenter into working for a quarter his normal price. Though with no one to maintain it properly the whole thing has been overrun by weeds.

“It’s funny, too, right in the center is the biggest damn rosemary bush I’ve ever seen. It’s got branches thick as a forearm, and leaves bigger than my head. There’s something not right about that plant. I never told you this, but when the commander stabbed you I could have sworn that this one bush… No, it sounds crazy. But you did come back, after all.”

Jonah reached into his pocket and pulled out the horse hair brush he had pocketed. He had been compelled to maintain it, perhaps as a concrete reminder of the sins he had committed, as to not let himself forget – or perhaps too because it had stirred some bizarre jealousy, that this alien child had been loved so deeply that someone would take the time celebrate him so. He had taken it to a woodworker who recommended a varnish for the handle and a mixture of lye and animal fat to clean the head, so when he pulled it out it was nearly in better condition than when he found it.

“I did a really bad thing, Isaac,” he whispered, not wanting Mary to overhear him, but three years past due for a confessional.

“I killed a boy before his time. It haunts me. Every night I dream about him, and the easy dreams are the ones where I relive his death over and over. Because the hard dreams are the ones where I picture what his life might have been like. Would he have become the village chief, or a painter? Would he have married and had children or been a lifelong bachelor as the heartthrob of the village? Could he have learned five languages and traveled the world, or would he have stayed at home and taught village children how to read and write?”

Jonah brought the brush level with the bed and ran a thumb through the thick hair.

“The worst nightmare is when I picture him sitting in his room alone, chewing on his nails just like Mary does. I can feel his anxiety and worry, because I know it. I know what it’s like to feel like the world is crumbling around you, that feeling that everything has gone terribly wrong, just as I know that it’s a pointless feeling. But he never got to figure that out. Because of me. And now Mary is being locked into the life of a caretaker. Also because of me. One wrong to make another wrong. It’s such a waste, Isaac. What’s the point?”

Isaac moaned, but did not stir.

“I hate myself so much. I think every day about all of the things that I should have done but didn’t because I was afraid. I should have told you the night it happened. I should have stood up to the commander, to the duke. I should have told Mary how I felt the first day I met her. I should have fucking killed myself while we were on the cliffside on the march to Orengarde. Everyone would have been better off.”

Isaac shifted, and to Jonah’s incredulity he watched as a bony hand raised itself from the bed. The rail-thin figure flexed at his torso and stretched until wilting fingers grasped the handle of the brush. Jonah breathlessly pushed the brush into his friend’s hand and helped him close his fingers around it. He ran out of the room to get Mary, but despite their best efforts to reproduce the miracle, Isaac did not stir again.

April 6th, 503 p.d.

It was two days until Mary and Isaac’s wedding, and Jonah could not stop thinking about it. For the first time in three years Isaac had moved – it was the miracle he had been praying for every night since the battle, that he had been begging for Markus to bring about but that he had produced. Himself. He thought of the confession he had when Isaac was last fully present, and guilt stabbed at him. Guilt that had never really gone away after all this time, but stayed in the pit of his stomach slowly slicing at him whenever a brief moment of mirth or joy stumbled unintentionally upon him. How good it would feel for Isaac to embrace him and say – ‘I forgive you, Jonah. You are an imperfect person in an indifferent world, but it’s not all your fault’. Would he be able to sleep through the night then, or allow himself to indulge in some small occasional pleasure as payment for the toils of the day? Could he clamber up the walls of this ditch he was digging for himself, with nowhere to go but further down?

“Jonah,” the cleric’s voice pleaded. “Please, you have to focus.”

Jonah was startled back into the small basement room beneath the cathedral. The cleric from the battlefield was looking at him, eyes filled earlier with apprehension now exuding desperate frustration. Jonah had his hands ungloved placed against each other, and he pulled them apart in wonder as if forgetting that he had cut his left palm open just a few minutes ago.

“I keep telling you this,” the cleric continued, crouching beside him. “It’s not going to work if you’re distracted. The last thing you want to do is let your mind wander while you’re trying to patch someone back up.”

Jonah breathed out and tried to think of something that would calm him, but all that came to mind was the look of pain on Isaac’s face as he choked to death on his own blood. The cleric sighed and put a hand on Jonah’s and warmth flowed from one man to the other and he opened his palm and saw his hand was healed.

“Let’s try again next week. Here, Jonah,” the cleric handed him a string of beads. “Tonight, try praying the rosary from start to finish without interruption. Or count backwards from two hundred, or count the fibonacci sequence, or recite all the names of the people you knew in school. It doesn’t matter what you do, just sit down for five minutes and do it.”

The cleric stormed off, muttering to himself. Jonah felt bad, knowing that he was adding to the kid’s mounting responsibilities. Why couldn’t he do this? More evidence to the pile that something was deeply wrong with him.

Jonah stood and with a deep sigh left the room to begin his morning duties. First was his morning training with the new paladin recruits. Now that he was in charge of development of the next generation, the last thing he wanted was for swordplay to be minimized in favor of decorum – you never knew when you would be called upon after all. After terrorizing the resentful city guard for a few months, forced to comply upon the mayor’s orders, Jonah felt he at least had a grasp on the basics, and he mixed these simple techniques with basic conditioning for his training regiment. Many had dropped already, likely drawn by aspirations of the very sinecure that had sorely disappointed Jonah when he enlisted as a teenager. He was just grateful that the remaining four recruits showed some amount of discipline, and though Markus gave him a hard time for three of them being female, he did not turn them away.

Next, stinking with sweat, he met with a couple of the clerics to hear their reports on the logistics of managing the church. Standing as far away from him as could be considered polite, the two he had hired to replace those felled in battle not fully acclimated to the stench of male perspiration, the head cleric and her assistant rattled off the various problems of the day. Funds from the most recent lavish donations lubricated by the mayor’s silver tongue were running dry, so they had begun to reach into the large reserves accumulated over the years from donations and tithes. Markus, who had complained about Jonah’s insistence to shut down revenue from the latter, would surely have some choice words from him on this later.

The nobles, who had been fascinated by their perception of Mary’s inhuman dedication to her fiance, were thrilled at the news of the wedding and wanted it to be lavish, so all of the church staff were scrambling to arrange as luxurious a celebration as possible in under a week. Jonah nodded along to talks of cleaning up the mayor’s garden for the ceremony and the slaughter of not ten but fifteen cows, thinking all the while how he might postpone it but finding no plausible way to stave off the aristocrats’ excitement.

The community kitchen that Isaac had dedicated himself to was overworked and undersupplied, as usual. The mayor never compromising on additional food beyond what the cardinal had negotiated, and Markus who despite his many complaints tended not to interfere with any of Jonah’s work explicitly prohibiting Jonah from supplementing their inventory with leftovers from the church’s meals, the days the kitchen was open were chaotic and increasingly dangerous. Jonah conceded to donate the time of two of his new paladins to supplement the city guard in the meantime, and asked the clerics to look into the feasibility of a public food donation program.

Finally, rats had been found in the wine cellars, so the head cleric had taken initiative and purchased a moderate portion of poison which was stored triple bagged in a store room near the cellar, and would be spread on the floors each night until the problem resolved.

The clerics dismissed, Jonah walked down from the small office, past the cardinal’s room, across the courtyard behind the cathedral to the barracks, and collected the two most competent recruits. They grumbled but followed, and together they walked down the long open staircase to the city. Jonah noted to himself that the gilded arms were beginning to dull – they would need to hire someone to polish the staircase. Maybe someone to cut back the out of control rosemary that had exploded from the hilltops and had recently begun to overtake the steps.

At the base of the stairs they proceeded south, walking through a litany of merchants and stalls. It was in the early hours of the day while shop owners were still setting up their displays, so the foot traffic was mercifully sparse. Perhaps because of this Jonah had a full view of the colorful textiles draped along one particular stand, a dead ringer for the cloth that had covered Orengarde’s city center. Jonah paused, letting the two recruits trundle on without him, memories of burning buildings threatening to overtake him. A small woman, unmistakably Orengardian with near translucent skin and jet black hair, emerged from below the stand with more fabric bundled in her arms, and paying him no mind she continued to drape layers of colors atop one another. Watching her attend to the delicate weavings, he could not avoid thinking of the boy’s portrait, and how this woman may have known the stranger who painted it – and thinking of the horse hair brush he had left in Isaac’s hand a terrible realization dawned upon Jonah.

He walked up to the woman and pointed at a yellow pattern into which small flowers were meticulously sewn.

“How much?”

The older woman scrutinized him, and for a moment he feared that she recognized him.

“You want dress? Scarf?” She asked in broken English, pantomiming the items.

“Just the fabric.”

The woman gave him a blank look, so Jonah just took out his entire coin purse and gave it to her. While she looked at it in awe he gently tugged his choice from the pile, rolled it into a ball, and marched in the opposite direction of his pupils.

He walked north across the city, passing the stairs to the church, and did not stop until he was at the doorstep of the house he had been at just the night before. He tried to push the door open but found it locked, so he pounded on it until Mary’s face emerged frazzled and annoyed from the doorway.

“Jonah? What are you doing here?”

He ignored her, pushing open the door and past her, and made his way into Isaac’s room. He lay in a similar position as he had left him, staring somewhere just off from the edge of the window.

“What’s going on?” Mary had followed him in.

Jonah hesitated, knowing that this moment would change everything. Would it be easier not to know? Probably. With shaking hands he took to corners of the shoddily folded yellow cotton and opened it in front of Isaac, praying that he was mistaken.

“Isaac, oh my god.”

The invalid’s hand twitched, and then his arm and torso were lifting to reach towards Jonah. He mutely held out the offering and draped it over a veiny arm, and the gaunt figure slowly reclined again, holding the fabric against his chest. Mary shrieked with excitement, and ran from the room, returning shortly with more colored fabrics, but Jonah just stood there in dumb denial. While the ecstatic woman dramatically waved around various blankets and tablecloths, Jonah slowly stepped backwards to the bay window overlooking the street, unlatched the nearest panel, and pushed it slightly ajar.

***

The kitchen had been a disaster that morning, and the new recruits were furious with him for abandoning them in the middle of the markets. Three of the church members volunteering had been stabbed, and the whole supply line had been overturned, with starving paupers swarming the building and ransacking it. Jonah had sat distracted through various meetings with clerics and guardsmen but could not for the life of him remember what had been said. It had all simply ceased to matter to him anymore.

It was after these meetings while he was reading monotone over a list of events of the day to the cardinal that the errant flash of one of the holy man’s many rings that the second realization of the day struck him. Something odd about this whole thing, indeed. Fury pounded through him, but with incredible restraint he politely excused himself, and the cardinal who had been only half-listening anyways waved him away, taking another swig of his vintage.

Jonah hurried over to the barracks again and began to rummage through the crude inventory. The besmirched recruits from that morning glared at him but said nothing while he dug like a madman through heaps of training swords and armor pieces until he found the small wooden crossbow hanging from a hook in a moldy storage area. More frantic searching revealed just two bolts at the bottom of a large chest.

“Almost,” Jonah whispered to himself, leaving the mess for the green paladins to deal with. He went to his room, leaving the crossbow and ammunition on a desk by his bed, then made his way down to the dressing rooms. A few of the male clerics were changing for a service tonight, including the one from the battle. Jonah grabbed the man’s thin arms and whirled him around to face him.

“I need something. A weapon that I don’t need to aim.”

The cleric stared at him, eyes wide, and tried to pry away from his grip, but Jonah just squeezed tighter.

“Now,” he growled.

The young man nodded violently, acquiescing, and half-clothed led Jonah to his room. He got onto the floor and reached underneath his bed to pull out a cloth sack. From it he produced a variety of items he had taken from the Orengardian battle field – intricately woven sheep-skin rags, colorful shirts and flowing pants, some choice selections of pottery that had been carefully wrapped back in the city with nondescript linens.

The cleric, flushing with shame, produced one final item and offered it to Jonah – a small egg-shaped object with a thin twine protruding from a small gap near the top.

“What will you use it for?”

Jonah pocketed the first-sized piece of metal and, ignoring the man who pilfered it, turned and walked out of the room. Near his next destination already, he made his way along the hallways leading between the cleric’s dormitories and the dressing rooms until, with a quick glance to make sure he was alone, he slipped inside the store room next to the cellars. In that room he found the bag nested within two just like itself and transferred some of the white powder into a satchel whose previous contents of dried herbs Jonah tossed behind a shelf.

Jonah snuck back to his room and arranged the items he would need tomorrow in front of him from left to right. His new saber, a plain steel thing he had requested have no ornamentation; the bag of white powder he had taken from the storage room near the wine cellar; the hand crossbow with two bolts; and finally, the egg shaped ball of iron.

Knowing that he would not be able to sleep with the adrenaline of the plan forcing him awake, he took the rosary the cleric had given him that morning and counted on each bed every wrong he had suffered, and then every wrong he had committed. Though the number was not an even one he continued, rotating the string of beads in his calloused fingers until the morning sun shone through his window.

April 7th, 503 p.d.

There was only one day left. Jonah spent most of it in his room, attempting to make up for the sleep he had failed to secure the night before. Though the rosary had helped, the pit of anxiety in his stomach was now threatening to pitch him into delirium while he tossed and turned on his cot. Eventually he gave up and stood in front of a shoddy, half-polished bronze plate he had requested from the cardinal when he took on his new job.

Jonah looked at himself in the warped reflection and laughed out loud. He had his own graying hairs now despite his relative youth; thin, unfriendly, and very bloodshot eyes through which you could barely make out amber irises; all highlighted by too prominent cheekbones jutting from a hallowed face, leading the viewer’s gaze down finally to a mess of unkempt facial hair. Jonah poked at the foliage on his upper lip and cringed, and as an opportunity to distract himself took the razor on a countertop near the makeshift mirror and shaved.

With his wiry facial hair now a pile on the floor, Jonah considered himself once more. It played no part in salvaging the horror that was his face above the nose, but his jawline was much sharper now. The brief moment of vanity triggered something in Jonah. Oddly enough, it felt like excitement. For the first time in his life, he would be taking the initiative. There was no Isaac to trail behind now, no leadership to blindly follow. Now there was just the plan.

Though he desperately wanted to meet with Mary one more time, he knew that he could not. So instead he alternated between fiddling with his weapons and fingering the string of beads until evening fell and the sounds of the church around him began to quiet. Once the sun had dipped fully beneath the horizon, it was time. Jonah donned his armor and prepared his weapons. Rapier in its scabbard; crossbow hooked onto a leather latch along his belt, bolts secured to his left wrist with some stray twine; satchel of powder in his left pocket, and last but certainly not least the ball of iron in his right.

Jonah gave one last look at his reflection in the sheet of metal. He was the fucking worm, damn it.

***

I hurt the woman I love by being too afraid to tell her what I really wanted.

Jonah walked across the church courtyard and made his way into the cathedral. The weight of his armor caused the old wooden steps to creak as he walked upstairs to the offices. Reaching the cardinal’s, he pushed open the door and walked in, closing it behind him. The cardinal was filling his cup from one of the large barrels he had asked to be installed, and he looked up in surprise.

“I need you to write Mary a recommendation to the mage’s guild in Southguarden.”

The cardinal scoffed.

“How will she manage that?”

Jonah unsheathed his rapier and, in the same way the commander had threatened him, leveled it at the old man. The official’s face fell as he looked down the length of the blade.

“You wouldn’t.”

“You had discussed with the Duke before he made his speech.” Jonah said flatly.

The cardinal’s eyes widened. “I… I don’t know what you’re talking about.”

“Now is not the time to lie to me, Markus.”

Leathery jowls bounced as he swallowed nervously. Saying nothing, he nodded to his desk and Jonah allowed him to sit and pen the letter. Once he signed the bottom, he held it out to Jonah, who with his free hand took it and quickly read through the contents. Satisfied, he handed it back for the pope to roll and seal it with wax.

The cardinal placed the letter delicately at the edge of his desk, and looked at Jonah.

“I have a lead on something that can help Isaac,” he told him seriously, perspiration beginning to dampen his balding forehead.

Jonah took the sealed letter, then ran his rapier through his neck. Leaving it embedded in his throat, he left the gurgling holy man, exiting the room and using one of many keys he had been granted to lock the door.

He walked down the steps leading from the office, down to the nave’s level, and then one level further, to make it to the cleric’s dormitories. He pushed into his favorite cleric’s room, who as if expecting him jumped from his bed in fear. He handed the quivering youth the letter.

“To Southgarden. Now. Please.” Jonah attempted a smile.

The cleric, looking as if he was about to be sick, took it and ran from the room.

Jonah clambered up the flight of stairs, and slowly trailed him as he rushed across the courtyard and down the long staircase lined with golden arms. He could see the cleric in the distance as he reached the bottom and veered west towards the aviary. Jonah diverged, and reaching the bottom went east.

I tried to bring my friend back from the dead so that he could forgive me for wronging him.

The moon high above him, Jonah went not to Mary’s door but to the panel he had left ajar last night. With a sigh of relief, he pulled it open without resistance, and so Jonah climbed into the room through the window. The sickly man lay amidst a sea of colorful textiles, clutching still the large square of yellow embroidered flowers. Jonah approached him and removing the satchel, poured all of the powder into a glass of drinking water that had been left by the bedside table.

He reached up to grab golden brown locks and gently tilted the invalid’s head back, slowly poured the mixture down his throat, stopping for a few seconds occasionally to allow the liquid to flow unobstructed into his stomach. The cup emptied, he returned it to the stand, and taking off his huge metal bracer he held the man’s hand as his breaths began to labor.

He coughed and gurgled and Jonah feared it would be loud enough to wake Mary, but it did not and eventually the sallow figure took his last breath.

“Rest in peace, stranger,” Jonah whispered, and then replacing his bracer left the dead man. He pushed the window panel open and hopped out onto the street, grateful that no insomniac neighbors were outside to witness him, and gently pushed the panel closed. Then he made his way west towards the mayor’s residence.

My sister was nearly assaulted, and when she ran away from home to save herself, I told her that I hated her for leaving me.

He reached the site of his many meetings with investors and famous travellers, and doggedly climbed up one final set of stone steps. Though it was nearly midnight, lamps were lit along the path towards the mansion, and he could make out light in the mayor’s main office. He pushed open the door, left unlocked for the late night guests, and made his way across the living room to the oak door that led into the mayor’s meeting space.

As he entered, he saw the mayor with his shirt off, lips pressed against a woman he did not recognize. The politician, hearing the rustling of armor, opened his eyes and pushed the woman away from him in surprise.

“Jonah,” he said, breathing heavily. “What the hell are you doing here?”

“The right thing, for once,” he replied simply, unhooking the crossbow from his belt and loading one of the bolts.

The mayor, seeing the weapon, whispered viciously to the prostitute. “Do something.”

The woman, eyes wide, began to speak strange words under her breath, her fingers forming patterns in the air, but just as she was about to cast the sorcery Jonah shot her in the stomach. Her eyes bulged and the spell careened away from its mark, clipping the edge of the weapon in Jonah’s hand with fire, ruining it. He tossed it onto a nearby shelf, and fingers of flame began to spread along expensive souvenirs and decorative books.

“You’ve lost your mind,” Louis spat at him.

I killed an innocent child because I was afraid.

“I’m the most sane I’ve ever been.”

Almost on cue, the light of the lamps began to skew and twirl, obscuring Jonah’s vision. The astigmatism caused beams of light to pierce across his vision, and as these beams bent and swirled a wave of nausea threatened to overtake him. Jonah grabbed the iron egg from his pocket and, nearly tripping over himself, shoved it into the fire he had just started on the shelf. Feeling the metal of his bracer heat and begin to sear the skin on his forearm, he prayed that a stray tongue of flame properly lit the fuse and threw it into the air.

The explosive detonated mid-air, and Jonah felt shrapnel pierce through his chest, ripping a hole in his ribcage. The obstruction to his vision abated somewhat, and he could make out the hazy figure of the mayor laying on the floor. Finding that he was having a hard time breathing, he pushed himself into an agonizing seated position and began to walk through his perverse rosary prayers.

I hurt Lucy because I was afraid. I hurt Mary because I was afraid. I hurt Isaac because I was afraid. I hurt an innocent child because I was afraid. I hurt myself because I was afraid.

Jonah felt a deep calmness fall upon him as he recounted the reality of his twenty-odd years at life. To his amazement, in spite of the grip of unconsciousness swirling around his head and the excruciating pain in his torso he felt a warmth flowing through his arms and chest and the gaping wound in his lungs and bones began to repair. A surge of energy filled him as blood vessels and connective tissue repaired themselves and oxygen began to return to his lungs.

Groaning he stood up and limped over to the fallen body of his Louis, and through the fading blurriness of his vision saw the faces of various deceptions flash across the figure’s bloody visage. He saw Louis’ face stretched in pain shift to the duke’s then shift to Isaac’s golden locks and innocent eyes. It held at the last image, and Isaac’s rendering peered into Jonah’s soul as if begging for mercy. Jonah just smiled sadly, and taking the final bolt in his fist plunged the arrowhead through the man’s skull.

Jonah stood, and though all pockets were emptied and weapons exhausted, he had one last thing to do. Taking one of the lamps off the walls of the smouldering room, he made his way out the building and into the massive garden just outside. It was a sea of rosemary, long since overtaken and suffocating any other plant life, with one central massive trunk towering over the rest in the center. Jonah tossed the lamp filled with kerosene into the center of the wild tangle of foliage and watched the mass slowly catch fire. He stayed long enough for the bushels of tiny green leaves burn away to reveal the mountain of bodies that lay beneath it, all decaying and rail-thin, the pile a collection over the years of cadavers of the starving homeless.

Jonah walked away, past crowds of soldiers and concerned citizens that had awoken to the sound of flames, past Mary’s mercifully somnolent house, past the massive gilded staircase leading up to the cathedral, and stopped at the gates of the city.

Without so much as a glance behind him he pushed open the gates.

Samson

I watched again through the side window, faced as it was opposite the entrance. More hole in the wall than window, even though they had the money for glass. I would be too embarrassed if I was on the road anyways. His bare back was to me, and I could see the taut thin muscles along his back, tight then loose as the hammer swings. Embers flew onto his forearms but he never flinched. Sweat dripped down along his neck – how sweet it looked glistening along his shoulders. Glazed Sam.

***

Done for the day, I put my shirt on and headed home. Quarter of a mile away I could already smell dinner; lamb, I think. I was glad we were away from the rest of town, what with dad cooking that sort of stuff. I looked up at the setting sun – maybe an hour or so until I meet that merchant girl. I can still feel her hand on my arm when she asked me, much softer than steel. For some reason I wasn’t very hungry.

Dad said nothing when I came in. The lamb was roasting over the firepit in the back, stuffed with herbs. Carrots, potatoes, and onions were sizzling in a pan beneath it, catching the dripping lamb juices. Bread that must have just been pulled out of the clay oven half an hour ago lined our one small table. I sat outside and waited, staring at the sky.

The sun was almost set by the time dad pulled the lamb off the fire. He brought it over to our little table with the vegetables and started to eat. I served myself some meat and ate quickly, trying to be inconspicuous. Dad wasn’t eating though – he just watched. I finished and accidentally made eye contact.

“More.”

I hesitated, then served myself more food and continued to eat. I couldn’t stop thinking about that hand. Fist could barely be the size of my hammer. This time, almost half of the food was gone before I moved to get up.

“More.”

I looked at dad, but couldn’t look at his face. Instead I stared at his chest. I was very full. I forced myself to eat.

There was two thirds of the food gone this time. A half pound left on the maybe two pound roast.

“I’m done,” I whispered. The food pushed angrily at my stomach. Dad shifted in his seat and grabbed the remaining lamb. Thank God, I thought, and almost made it to the door, right behind where dad was sitting.

“Wait.” I froze, then turned around. He was holding out the last of the lamb, his dirty fingers piercing into the tender flesh, juices dripping down his arm.

I stared back defiantly.

“No.”

I was suddenly on the ground. I could see black around the edges of my vision. By some miracle I kept myself from vomiting. Dad towered over me with the lamb pinched between his thumb and forefinger.

I took it and ate.

***

That boy don’t eat enough I cook this fine meal and he think he won’t eat the whole thing he’s kidding me no boy of mine will kid me

Men need to be big and strong big and strong

My father kneeled bloody-faced at the foot of the big man on the street. I pulled on his shirt that night and asked and he rained down righteous fury like he’d read to me. That big man’s fists falling on my face.

Big and strong.

***

I make my way across the field to the edge of the forest. There’s a rock that juts out about a mile in as long as you hang on the east, she said. Dinner exits just a few feet in, and I rinse my mouth with water from the river that flowed in from the mountains.

It is very dark by the time I get there, but moonlight is shining well enough I can see her waiting. She is not afraid like me and in the light she pushes me down.

***

Mama says it is the anticipation that is half the pleasure but how can anyone know what to anticipate the first time they chew honeycomb. Shipped in a glass jar that pa brings back after one of his long trips I thought it would be good so much I begged and cried until he relented but it was so much better and how could I have known.

***

I walk back to the river with her because it is very late and dangerous and I would not feel right leaving a girl by herself in these woods. We are almost back before I can see it drinking but by then it is too late. I can tell it is hungry just by looking at it just skin and bones but still a predator. Swiftly it turns when it smells us (we were downwind) and runs very fast so I push her to the side and hold up my hands not thinking. It goes for my throat but I hold open its jaws and pull pull pull and it is to my surprise quite easy. Like how I keep ruining the bellows.

***

That blacksmith kid has something wrong with him. I am telling this whenever I can to Mr. Wattington when along his route he stops by each month but he doesn’t believe it that his only daughter would have any interest in a day laborer and I think to myself you haven’t seen the way she looks at him when she thinks no one is looking, peeking in through the back every day as she does. Maybe wrong attracts wrong she looks like she wants to eat him.

I am thinking these things as I carry the water bucket to the river but stop when I realize that there is a smell. I follow it upstream and I’ll be damned but there is some huge wolf ripped damn near in two near the stone bridge, blood and guts all about. Chunks of flesh were missing, must have been picked at by other wolves already.

***
When I pull apart that wolf I can see a golden sheen pour out of it and so I bend down to look closer and it drips viscous syrup I hear my name called behind me but I do not care instead I am overwhelmed with the scent of sweetness and I have to taste

What is honey well I think it is when bad things get what is coming eating only when one wants to eat is there such a good thing packed inside every living thing

***

I am cooking three chickens tonight I get a good deal in exchange for all those goods my boy makes first I cut off their heads and bleed them then pluck out all their feathers then have to take all the guts out and tear out the legs when you make chicken your cut along the shoulder then along the thighs and then separate out the breast which you can cut into four chunks and then all of it goes into the pot with fresh water and bay leaves thyme rosemary garlic lots of salt and pepper then carrots potatoes celery and boil for two hours until all the meat is falling off the bones

Sam shows up in time for dinner with that merchant girl I serve him in our biggest bowl he has to eat at least three of them if he wants to grow up big and

He says no what boy of mine won’t eat this food took me three hours I’ll make him eat if I have to three hours

***

Tore his pa’s arm clean off why does he look that way at the open wounds

***

Is there a sweet gilded thing hidden inside every thing

***

Big and strong big and strong

The Ewe

David used to be a salesman, until he got lost in the woods. Now he was a dying one. He laid against a redwood facing a clearing in the forest and pondered his loss of interest in life. The sun rose above him, continuing an inexorable march westwards. Its halo etched into his vision until he forced himself to look away, blinking from the impression it left. 

Only then did he notice the lone sheep feeding nonchalantly in the open area in front of him. He was taken aback – there shouldn’t be any farm animals this far up in the mountains; certainly no sheep this well fed and groomed. His stomach clenched painfully, and his instinct for survival spurred him into action. He surreptitiously inched his hands towards the makeshift knife he kept in his pocket for hunting and slowly rose to his feet, but the ewe continued to eat – without even the courtesy of turning its head to assess the approaching figure.

David heard laughing and froze. He spun around, eyes wild, his knife held stiffly in front of him, but there was no one else in the clearing. Just him and the ewe. All the energy drained from his body and he sat himself suddenly on the ground, the knife falling from his hands.

I went out last night with this guy and he was really hot plus he’s already in medical school how can someone be that hot and that smart he’s probably too good for me I think that you should find somebody else you’re such a good friend that I wouldn’t want to hurt you and I’m not ready to date right now it’s still too soon I’m really jealous of my because I just want to date her partner so bad he’s so perfect ugh I hate people that sell things who would ever want the sex was so good how can I not call him he just won’t listen to what I say I want to be heard too I’m hot right

            David pressed the palms of his hands as tightly as he could into his ears.

            So I talked with and he said that she really did not want to go out with you what are you hoping for maybe a kiss she must be kind of into you if she was talking to you about it’s not official just because you’re going out to dinner once how do I look in these shoes I’m not the fancy dress kind of girl I think you should find someone else

            This goddamn sheep was laughing at him. Won’t even give him the time of day.

            “I could walk up and slit your throat right now you fucking animal,” David yelled. He waited for a response but the ewe continued her rumination, slowly plodding forward as she exhausted the greenery beneath her.

Won’t even look him in the goddamn eye.

            What’s wrong with me why am I is it my body I’m kind of flabby I don’t like the way my face looks eyebrows too strong acne scars really skinny arms don’t work out I’m not very smart I failed that one class I’m not good at memorizing things am I funny I’ve been told I’m not don’t pick up on things really creepy can’t take a hint doesn’t want me to sit next to him I’m annoying bad personality really desperate don’t even have a job wouldn’t impress her why am I so

            The grass beneath his feet pulled at his legs, the emptiness of the woods around him pressing on him like hands.

            At least I’m not this sheep though it’s all alone has no man just walks around and eats all day pathetic broken so bad it doesn’t even notice I’m here I could sneak behind it and bam sure is quiet up in the woods even birds don’t like me everything hurts bet a grand this animal got abandoned for it’s honestly grotesque would have been tossed anyways no one wants that wool must be wondering why it was born if all the things it wanted it couldn’t have this ewe isn’t a woman it can’t even attract a ram must be lonely ears too big and wool not combed and slits for eyes

            David tried to force himself to laugh but he didn’t feel the situation was especially funny. If anything, he felt sympathy for the pathetic creature that stood eating before him. How sad of a life to wander around the mountains by oneself.

            This sheep is just asking for it back turned and all she wants it can’t even get a ram I’ll show her a man

            He quivered with excitement and groped around wildly for his knife. He rose quickly and, after a moment of nausea, stomped loudly towards the ewe to make sure she knew he was coming. He came up behind her and froze at the last second, shaking in anticipation. She really was a beauty. Slowly he reached out with his free hand to touch her fur.

            This is what I want right

            The ungulate rose up on her front legs and slammed her back hooves into David’s chest. Ribs shattered, and the ex-salesman collapsed in a heap on the ground gasping for air. He looked up, fury pounding through the pain, and watched as she stepped into his view, blocking the rising sun. She looked down and met his gaze with golden irises. Searing.

            She wants

            The ewe turned and walked out of view to the west.

Summary of Henderson Article

Henderson, Mae G. Re-membering the Body as Historical Text. Toni Morrison’s Beloved: a casebook, pg 81-106. Oxford University Press, 1999. New York.

            In order to fully engage with the future, Henderson argues, one must construct a sense of individuality by creating meaning from the unspeakable memories of their past – in Sethe’s case, by wiping herself of the myth of the master (or her master’s) narrative and telling her own story as both a slave and a mother. As we discussed in class, Beloved emerges in response to the flagrant, although not altogether startling, omission of female slave narratives, attempting to imagine the accounts of “…the women and children who left no written records.” (82) Within this vacuum emerges an opportunity to redefine the contemporary understanding of slavery by breaking into the reproductive reality of alienated maternity and sexual abuse. In the same way that Morrison pieces together a story from narratively isolated memories, Henderson interprets Sethe’s journey throughout the novel to be one of emplotment and re-figuration; piecing together memories to create a story, and then re-engaging with them to change their meaning and their significance to herself in the present and the future. As such Morrison and her protagonist are paralleled in the process of deconstructing the pallid master narrative in order to bring to light opaque truths of slavery, and demonstrate the challenge of coming to terms with the weight of the past. Henderson reveals the importance of open dialogue with the then in order to understand the now and create the after – and yet grapples with the frustration of ultimate destruction in the process.

            Perhaps less emphasized, but no less fascinating, are Henderson’s themes of the physicality of the past in the present. Elaborating on the inscription of Beloved’s name upon her tombstone as a symbol of the trace she leaves behind in the world as memory, she describes the way “… the master has inscribed the master(‘s) code on Sethe’s back,” (86). There is significance to the way Sethe’s body acts as a template upon which her owner can write – narrative and trauma is generated not simply through text and law, but also through the physical implications and applications upon its victims. Furthermore, schoolteacher “… [appropriates] Sethe’s ‘milk’ through a process of phallic substitution…[using] the pen… to ‘re-mark’ the slave woman with the signature of his paternity.” (90) Referring to Sethe’s rape scene, in which schoolteacher’s nephew forcibly nurses from her, Henderson’s focus on material symbols belies that even beyond literary technique, the past and future are inevitably linked to objects in the present, and implies that the damage of slavery includes the denial of physical things in the future – children, touch (the nerve-deadened skin on Sethe’s back), and perhaps even skin ship between emotionally damaged individuals.

            Henderson more concretely discusses the idea of the Other, and it’s significance in creating identity for the self. When analyzing Baby Sugg’s wordless reaction to Sethe’s scars, she describes the presumption that “…[black women] can be written and written upon precisely because they exist as the ultimate Other, whose absence… only serves to define the being or presence of the white or male subject.” (87). Henderson describes here how black women serve as a template upon which the identity of the master narrative is created – a narrative defined by all of the ways white males are not like black women (an idea, as we’ve read about in class, that Morrison herself has written about). To further complicated the matter, Henderson brings in the concept of “self-distanciation” from Morrison, in which “… ‘the self [is] really a twin or a thirst or a friend or something that sits right next to you and watches you.” (92). Morrison describes here the way in which women can project their value of their own life onto something other than themselves – and Beloved acts perfectly as this other, connecting “… the individual to repressed aspects of the self, as well as to… others.” (93). Beloved mirrors the otherness of Sethe and the black women in her community, and must be expelled in order to develop a sense of self that is not defined by trauma. In this way Henderson creates an interesting parallel between the way whiteness exists only relative to blackness, and the way projection of Sethe’s repressed self must be engaged with to move beyond. 

            In order to create the framework for Henderson’s ideas of memory creation, organization, and significance, she brings in Paul Ricoeur’s notions of “… prefiguration [denoting] the temporality of the world of human action; configuration, the world of the narrative emplotment of these events; and refiguration, the moment at which these two worlds interact and affect each other,” (100). In context of these philosophical ideas, Sethe, according to Henderson, configures a narrative, with a plot, by using prefigured re-memories, and triggered by Beloved, is forced to re-figure the meaning of these memories and the collective story she has created out of them in order to deliver the future. Ricoeur’s framework allows a structured approach to the novel, in which repeatedly Sethe, her children, and her peers create stories out of memories (their own and others’) in order to make sense of their lives. In a similar vein, Henderson cites Morrison’s process of “literary archeology” as “… ‘[moving] the veil aside’ in order to penetrate the ‘memories within’.” (83). In the same way that Sethe has pre-figured (experienced and consolidated) her own memories, Morrison uses the act of imagination to generate memories that can then be communally configured and refigured.

            In addition to the philosophical and critical frameworks provided, Henderson strives to emphasize the importance of psychoanalysis in her reading of the novel. Quoting Norman Brown – “… ‘the method of psychoanalytic therapy is to deepen the historical consciousness of the individual (“fill up the memory gaps”) till [she] awakens from [her] own history’”. (92). According to Henderson, the process Sethe and Morrison go through to create a sense of individuality and identity for black female slaves echoes the process a practitioner of psychotherapy might use when working with a patient. There must be some level of interaction with the past, some construction of a functional internal narrative, before the patient may “awaken” from the nightmare of their trauma and move on. The use of these analytical tools seems to pay off during analysis of the end of the novel, when Sethe “…re-enacts the original event… This time, however, [she] directs her response to the threatening Other rather than to… “her children.” (100) Following this reading, Sethe’s conflation of Edward Bodwin with schoolteacher becomes a re-figured history, in which Sethe is placed in the same situation that led to her infanticide, except she has changed the significance of her past, and thus redirects violence upon the antagonist rather than her children.

            Henderson’s article reads very insightfully into the nature of Morrison’s intentions of examining the creation of history and the parallels it has with Sethe’s creation of her individual history. The act of re-membering, emplotment, and re-figuring are impossible to deny in the text – each of Sethe’s narrations engage in traumatic memories, and the novel is founded upon the painful process of confronting the past. Henderson also aims to address the ending as fairly as possible – she does not claim that Sethe is herself redeemed by Morrison, nor does she imply that she has been necessarily healed of her trauma either. Rather, in her view, the novel instead celebrates the process of refiguration rather than its results – a fair assessment of a story entrenched in moral ambiguities and disregard, and that emphasizes the physical and mental permanence of traumatic events. If there is one thing Henderson did not elaborate upon, however, it is the significance of Denver in process of moving beyond the past. Denver, unlike her mother, engages with and overcomes her own trauma successfully, and is arguably the most important symbol for what is at stake in Sethe’s re-figuration process – the next generation.

Walter

              Walter’s lips were chapped. More so, he felt as if all his saliva had been meticulously patted out with a cotton cloth and his mouth left to wither with all the grace of a field of blighted crops in East Sannad. For some reason, the crowd of dozens of eminent sociologists and historians patiently waiting for him to begin intimidated him far more than his homefield crowd of arcane scientists and specialists. He had been studying arcana his whole life, but sociology was new ground. The straightforward mechanical processes that defined scientific study were nowhere to be found in the oral mythology of the Iravon halflings that introduced him to social studies, much less any concrete answers to their generations of racial conflict, and this frustrated Walter. If you’re having problems programming your summoned mud golems to use a pickaxe correctly, then it’s simply a matter of correcting your summoning incantation. That’s what books are for, and worst-case scenario, it’s a straightforward process of re-summoning and re-writing and recording until the behavior you want is developed and reproducible. But how are you supposed to solve halflings? Iravon halflings may be unusually congenial with most other species, but even they don’t get along with Urivon halflings, and time and time again history has shown that forcing these groups together for any extended period of time is asking for trouble, even though they have existed in relative proximity for years, secretly elope and intermarry, and have painfully obvious common roots in their respective oral traditions.

              Walter wasn’t here just to talk about Iravon halflings however – he was preoccupied with, inconceivably, something that could be considered a solution to a problem in a field defined by its lack of solutions to problems. The scholars that he was slowly making measured eye contact with around the room had all but vowed to take a purely journalistic and theoretical approach, never daring to offer a fix to any of the various social issues that seemed so obvious to an outside party. To be fair, giving a three hour dissertation to a crowd of illiterate goblins that all hate both you and each other has never ended well – and hyperbole aside, it is a very different thing to live through conflict than it is to observe it; Walter knew that very well. However, this was a case study in cultural enlightenment that potentially could pioneer a new way of interacting with the creatures of the world, and Walter was the first to write about it, thanks to the help of Virfaren. It was the academic fame he got from this discovery that led him to talk at this conference, and the childlike surge of pride he got knowing that everyone here must have read his paper finally motivated him to begin.

              “Thank you, all, for coming to this conference that my mentor, Dr. Margaret Butler, has so generously taken the time to organize. I understand that everyone is quite busy with their own research and teaching obligations, and am humbled at the incredible turnout of this event in spite of this. My name is Walter Douglas, and I am a fifth year graduate student at Westport University [Coast south of Beacon Hills]. I actually began my graduate career at Coldmont [along the Northern Mauvre] studying the mechanics and design of mud golems, specifically in conjunction with the magical equipment my hometown specializes in, until I found myself in contact with Margaret and she introduced me to her work on the Iravon peoples of Sannad. Pushed by her, and a series of transformative personal events, I transferred to Westport and began to work on the Iravon myself, until through my work with them I found out about the Elberos Clan, whom I will be talking about today.

              “To those unfamiliar with Margaret’s work, the Iravon are a group of halflings that have populated the Sannad region for at least the past five centuries, if not longer. Following the common stereotypes of halflings to, perhaps, a fault, this group is well known for their geniality and loquaciousness – fantastically hospitable, and more than capable of befriending even inanimate objects if, for some reason, they feel the need. However, those that take the time to explore the history behind these delightful individuals will find that even the friendliest, seemingly well-adjusted races cannot escape the violent tension the rest of us are too intimately familiar with. The Urivon are a much sparser organization of halflings, scattered randomly across the outer, malnourished regions of Sannad [Somewhere in the Andin Desert?]. Embittered against the Iravon for pushing their own peoples many generations ago into these blighted, dangerous areas, much of the interaction between the two comes in either formalized regional skirmishes or bloody guerilla warfare. Countless centuries of violence, and little military success on the part of the of the Urivon, has solidified an internalized hatred on both parts that has no end in site. Fifty years ago foreign intervention attempted to abolish boundaries and force integration of the Urivon into the more populated and fertile lands near the center of Sannad, which resulted in a fierce conflict that exhausted foreign military support and nearly the entire Urivon population along with it. It is only after five decades of jaded diplomacy and a complicated and culturally hypocritical, if understandable, surge of nationalism that the Iravon have again embraced a more open relationship with the outside world, under the understanding that they will not tolerate such an intrusion into personal affairs again. Margaret’s research focuses on this complicated history, attempting to understand this paradoxical people and the root cause to their hatred of the Urivon.

              “Just over a year ago, as I was transcribing histories in Davpos, a recently established trading hub northeast of Oseon, the capital of Sannad, I was introduced to an older gentlewoman Iravon halfling named Yolyse. An avid adventurer, Yolyse had spent most of the past century abroad, travelling with her wife and friends who all shared this incredible wanderlust that I have never seen before. I spent all night listening to her stories, and just as she was about to leave the next day, for Oseon, and then to who knows where, I remembered myself and asked what she, as someone who has spent her life exploring the world, thinks about the Urivon. She gave me a look I’ll never forget – some cross between anger and sadness, the inner conflict visible upon her features, and then she pulls a slip of parchment from her bag, tells me to write down the question, and leaves. Familiar with such things from my past, I realized it was very likely enchanted, and expecting it to be some form of communication with Yolyse, I wrote down the question, addressed it to her, and signed my name. The words faded from the paper, confirming my suspicion, but the next day when I examined it I found that I was not, in fact, communication with Yolyse, but instead an individual named Virfaren, head of something they called the Elberos clan.

              “After a lengthy, and frustratingly slow, I admit, discourse, I discovered that the Elberos clan is a group of Elves that live in a hidden location somewhere in the Tegell Woods. Consisting mostly of ex-patriates and outcasts, what makes this this clan unique, as you all have read, is their ground-breaking ideology. Populated by those that have seen the worst consequences of racial conflict, the Elberos people have worked for centuries on methodically squeezing the last vestiges of their own innate prejudices and creating a society that benefits on diversity of opinion and character. It is an incredible, concerted, intellectual attempt to tackle and deconstruct some of the worst underlying issues of intelligent creatures with rigorous scientific and sociological method. Fundamentally, this society is based on using time to their advantage – the best way to work through the myth of race is to critically examine and experience many different species and types of people. According to Virfaren, eventually, you can convince even the most prejudiced of individuals of the inherent equality of the denizens of this earth.

“Six months of communication later I asked Virfaren for proof of the existence of this clan, and so he and some of his companions traveled all the way down to the cost of the Beacon Hills and met with me in person. When he arrived I admittedly interrogated him rather viciously, but I am confident in the veracity of his claims. I have never before heard of such a structure for any sort of society, but I am cautiously hopeful that this might be the start, at least, of a greater era of social enlightenment.

              “I am honored to say that I have been extended an invitation to stay with and study the Elberos Clan, and am looking forward to returning with novel insights into this incredible lifestyle. Before I go, however, I am happy to introduce the leader of the clan himself, Virfaren, to talk for a while on his concepts of race as an arbitrary categorization of individuals, and his means of combatting its grip on the minds of the prejudiced.”

              A tall, dark-skinned elf strode confidently onto the stage, clothed in neat, academic collared shirt and slacks that not unintentionally resembled Walter’s attire. He gave a polite nod to Walter as they passed each other, then reached the podium and introduced himself. Virfarin used the next couple of hours to speak on the particulars of his clan, elaborating on the way they factored their diverse voting base into their political system, the methodology behind systematically eliminating bigotry, and various other particulars of interest to the sociologically inclined.

              Very satisfied with the night, Walter left Virfarin to answer questions, knowing he would be the focal point amongst the crowd, and walked back to his room. Once he arrived at his building, one of the nicer dorms on his campus specifically for grad students, he turned away from the entrance and walked around to the back. Disposing of his coat and bag behind a hedge, Walter nimbly clambered up the towering kapok tree that rose from the side of a sizeable garden that decorated the rear courtyard, careful to avoid damaging his formal wear, and waited patiently on a large branch halfway up, enjoying the tropical nighttime breeze. Walter didn’t have to wait long for a familiar rustling, and he did not start when a deep voice greeted him from his side.

              “How was your talk?” It inquired politely.

              “Perfect. They ate it up – once I return from the Tegells I’ll be famous, I’m sure of it,” Walter responded confidently.

              “And then?”

              “And then… and then I think I can finally find peace for what has happened. I don’t want revenge, Arthur. I just want to understand – and, if I can, help people avoid what has happened to us.” There was silence, and Walter let it hang as he strained his eyes to see the stars over the coastline.

              “What about you?” Walter finally asked. “Still determined to get your revenge?”

              “Always. You were too young to remember our parents… but I do.” Arthur’s voice was more wistful than it was angry. “Our father was a good man.”

              “To his family, perhaps,” Walter countered. “He was an angry man as well.”

              “Can you blame him? Decades of poverty, humiliation, starvation. I would be angry too.”

              “Still. There’s no excuse for violence. What happened to our people was unacceptable, but our father’s anger cost everyone’s life.”

              “Our lives were forfeit anyways. They were just looking for an excuse to get rid of us.”

              “And our father provided it. I understand that he was not the only one to blame. But I also understand that there are other ways to deal with injustice. Better ways. I want justice too, but not if it costs the lives of others – because if so, how are we any better?”

              “You’re still too young Walter. You don’t realize that in the real world, there aren’t always pretty ways to wrap up conflict. All that truly matters is power – and once I get it…” Arthur let the implicit threat hang. The anger in his voice was palpable now, and Walter shuddered silently, cringing even though it wasn’t directed at him. There was more silence, and then rustling once again, this time signaling that Arthur was about to leave.

              “Arthur, wait,” Walter said suddenly. “Even if we don’t agree on this, you’re my brother. I don’t want you to throw you life away for no reason. Please, you’re the only connection I have to my past.”

              Arthur hesitated, then said, “I will be careful. I can’t get my revenge if I die like an idiot beforehand. I’m going to Sli’raac.”

              “Sli’raac? That place doesn’t exist Arthur.”

              “No!” Arthur insisted. “It’s real – and it has what I need to defeat the mages that killed our father and murdered our village. I can’t risk attacking them without some way of combatting their magic – and there is something there that can help me. The sands are quivering now, Walter. All roads lead to Sli’raac.”

              Walter said nothing, and just reached out in the darkness and squeezed his brother’s arm before letting him go. He hadn’t mentioned it during his talk, but the halfling Yolyse had said that she was heading there next as well. He had asked how she was so sure it actually existed, and she responded in an eerily similar way to his brother.

              “We’re going because now is our time. That’s just where you end up among my type.” When asked to clarify, she simply shrugged her shoulders and changed the subject, and he had thought nothing of it, until now. Sli’raac was a myth he had heard long ago from his adoptive parents, a fairy tale about a desert sanctuary for travelers. There was a lot of conjecture that had been thrown about, that he could tell wasn’t necessarily true because of the way it conflicted with other information he had heard. His mother would say that it was so wonderful that no one ever wanted to leave, so legendary a place that even nomads couldn’t refuse finally settling down. His father would claim the opposite, that it was so dangerous that the thrill attracted the masses, but no one ever made it out alive. His friends amongst the village would demand that it contained countless riches, secrets to immortality, tremendous power to strike down your enemies – all the fantastic stuff one might expect fanciful children to contrive. Even some of the faculty at his university would claim to have met individuals who had known individuals that had personally interacted with other individuals and so on all claiming one thing or the other. Now, though, maybe there was some validity to the story – it was notable that two people he knew firsthand were travelling there.  Worried for the safety of his brother, but all too aware that there was very little he could do to guarantee it, Walter went to bed to ready himself for his journey to the Tegell Woods tomorrow.

              When he left his dorm with his pack of things the following morning, Virfaren and his group of elven companions were waiting for him. The trek north would take a few months normally, but Walter and the elves were fit, fast walkers, and so wove their way through the Beacon and Slate Hill mountain ranges in a matter of weeks. Walter was raised to study magic ever since childhood – he was given the best education money could offer, and first-hand tutoring on the intricacies of summoning golems and using them to automate manual labor. However, his real passion was exercise– every gene in his body screamed for him to exert himself, much to the consternation of his sedentary community, and so more often than not Walter found himself exploring the jungle around him. He would hike miles at a time, walking along the Mawre River to orient himself, and climbing trees to investigate the surrounding area. After using said trees to narrowly escape the more dangerous local fauna a few too many times, he started sneaking away unenchanted swords from his town’s armory, and creating makeshift shields out of palm fronds, chunks of bark, and vines. Finally his parents hired a travelling mercenary to formally train him in swordplay under the agreement that he focus on his arcane studies as well, and his success in the latter eventually led to his studying abroad to pursue higher education.

               His progress in magical studies was notable, and he was on the fast track towards formally becoming a respectable industrial wizard in his own right, when his brother Arthur finally found him. Arthur and Walter are the spitting image of each other, although Arthur is more light-skinned, like their parents. This combined with the accuracy of his recollection of their hometown, and a later admission when Walter confronted his parents with the information, convinced him of the veracity of his brother’s claims.

              Many generations ago, a group of veteran combat mages who made it rich off their success during some major contemporary conflict were exploring the Curtupach Jungle, and found a vast network of gold mines clustered a few miles off the western Olen coast. Unwilling to do the mining work themselves, and as of yet unaware of the wonders of automation with golems, one of the mages got in contact with a war friend that he knew was part of a wandering mercenary family and offered to pay them a tidy wage, as well as provide a large amount of land that would fall under the magical protection of the town the mages were in the process of constructing. Weary from the war, and incentivized by the generous sums far greater than what was offered at the time for hired swords, the group accepted, and for a long while worked happily in the mines in the newly created, and very cleverly named, town of Gildmond. However, after a generation or so, leadership changed as it must over time, and a wizard raised with a taste for the finer things in life decided the wages being paid to the miners were too high for unskilled labor and would simply not do any longer.

              In response to the outrage on the part of the miners, and the threats of abandoning the town all together, the wizard organized a group morally ambiguous town members and laced the surrounding area with magical traps. The ex-mercenaries, knowing nothing of the arcane arts, soon learned the hard way they could not leave the area without risk of obliterating themselves, and all too aware they would stand no chance against a town full of powerful wizards, quietly returned back to the mines for the lower wages. As these things go, wages continually were lowered, and quality of life proportionally decreased. In addition, the roles of each group became further cemented in the town’s politics – obviously, no high born wanted to do the grimy manual labor, and no mercenaries were ever allowed to try their hand at magic. As time progressed, the lack of genetic influx into the increasingly segregated mining area led to miscarriages and birth deformities, both contributing to the narrative of their inferiority. The mages on the other hand were making significant strides in their own development of novel magic, and eventually used their wealth to branch into the business of weapon enchantments. As trade and wealth exploded, the final tipping point for the miners ended up being the introduction – by foreign, more technical wizards – of mud golems. Suddenly, there was no need for miners, and the magical traps were lifted and they were told to go on their way. However, decades of abuse, unpaid wages, and threats of violence had been at the boiling point for a while now, and the loss of the mining job was the last straw. Generations later, these institutionalized people remembered nothing of their tenacious, mercenary ancestors; now, they were mining folk through and through, and to their knowledge, crippled by lack of contact with the outside world, there was nowhere else to go.

              While the populist elected leader of the miners was arguing for their job back with the mayor of Gildmond at the time, David Jacobson, in the middle of the developed part of the town, one choice insult of a particular physical deformity on the young leader pushed him over the edge, and in a fit of passion he jumped on David and beat him to death with his bare hands in the street; that man was Walter’s father. According to Arthur, who was only eight at the time, everyone was too shocked to do anything except watch as two centuries of anger manifested itself in the bloody fists of the passionate youth that fell, again and again, upon the bloody corpse of the mayor. Before anyone could react, Arthur gathered himself and sprinted away to hide in, of all things, an empty crate in an alleyway– and what followed was a bloodbath. First it was the miners in the center of town that came to argue with their father. Then it was all those unaware back in their squalid section of the town who had emerged in response to the sound of screaming. Then it was all those in the process of escaping, or those in the mines collecting their things, or those fishing along the river. Years of prejudiced disregard and dehumanization, coupled with the righteous, blinding anger at the murder of their mayor, spelled genocide for everyone that Walter could potentially call blood. Last of all was his father – Arthur, who still was hiding in town, witnessed firsthand what happened to him. The sadistic, ceremonial nature of the event eventually gave him the chance to escape back to what was left of his home. By some miracle, the infant Walter was alive, but before his brother could find him he was picked up by a sympathetic family that came to explore the ruins of the mining village rather than take part in the torture. Arthur took hope in being unable to find his brother’s corpse and escaped south to the Poisoned Weald where he, orphaned and alone, he was recruited by a gang of hired killers and trained as an assassin.

              Walter on the other hand was raised completely unaware of his origins – according to his parents, he was adopted from some major city in the west they had conveniently traveled to after the massacre, and had fortunately avoided any of the genetic consequences of inbreeding that ran rampant throughout his biological family. The entire thing was never formally addressed afterwards – efforts to spread the word of what happened were quickly and efficiently silenced, and the entire thing faded away into history. Upon learning of this, and surreptitiously confirming the story with his parents, Walter quietly transferred schools, disgusted with his magical history, and feeling utterly betrayed by those that raised him. Instead he threw himself into sociology in an attempt to understand how bias can embed itself within the framework of society so deeply that it could lead to the annihilation of some arbitrarily defined group of people. Arthur’s critique of Walter’s motivations were accurate, though, and so cut all the deeper – in spite of this initial repulsion, what really motivated him now were academic reasons. He enjoyed immersing himself in academic work; sociology, even if at times frustrating, scratched the same itch for Walter as arcana – and frankly he didn’t feel the same loss as his sibling. His childhood was a good one, overall – little in the way of racial tension. The most interpersonal conflict Walter experienced as a kid was the occasional argument over compensation in the marketplace, and he would be lying to himself if he denied it helped that the entire village all looked and talked and walked the same. In spite of this, Walter was very driven in his work, academic enjoyment aside. He had spent his life solving technical problems when summoning mud golems – and now his problem was a bit more abstract, a bit more complex, but he was determined to solve it.

              Virfaren was a genial, talkative elf that enjoyed reasoning through his thoughts out loud, juxtaposing Walter’s own tendency to silently percolate on matters before feeling comfortable enough to speak on them. Much of the journey to the Tegells involved Virfaren monologuing, with the occasional comment or opinion thrown in by either Walter or his companions. Walter didn’t mind one bit – he knew he had a lot to learn, and in spite of his tendency to rattle on Virfaren was a fascinating, intellectually stimulating individual. Nobody Walter had met before had quite the same perspective on the world as this elf did, nor such a strong passion for nature. Virfaren did all the standard nature-y things that woodland elves did: communicate with trees and forest spirits, discuss local politics with the woodland critters, and pay due respects to all of their predators. More significantly, though, were the times he would join Walter in the treetops when they would rest, or when he would wistfully stare into the distance atop mountain vistas, one of the few times he would say very little. Landscapes, he told Walter, comforted him – he always felt safer lost in the woods than in civilization, and would often joke that he had become an old recluse after so much time spent away from populated areas.

              It was from Virfaren that Walter began to rediscover a love of magic once again. One of the other members of the Elberos clan that went by Elaith would spar with him periodically, and after the seventh or so consecutive loss, Virfaren suggested using simple spells as a means of enhancing Walter’s swordplay. Walter would experiment with creating illusions, or flashes of light, to distract Elaith just long enough for him to land a hit, and the thrill of victory was exhilarating. This continued once they reached the hidden location of the Elberos clan, where Walter quickly established himself as a fixture. Surrounded by elves that after decades or centuries of study and travel became critical social philosophers in their own right, he found no want for conversation. He took great pleasure in talking with the fifty or so lasting members and transcribing their ideas on constructing healthy societies and working with racist groups. In addition, Virfaren worked very closely with Walter to engrave the Elberos ideology into his very soul – most important of these the valuing of the individual. Walter admittedly struggled with this – how was he supposed to value the life of people that didn’t value his own? Virfaren would always reply that the cycle of violence must end somewhere, and that it was his responsibility as a future social leader to work with the most difficult people to accept change.

              What originally was supposed to be just a couple of years of study became five years, then ten, then twenty. Periodically he would leave with some group members for various reasons, such as to officially receive his degree, publish more writings, or interact with conflicting peoples in an attempt to de-escalate the situation. During these times he would inquire about his brother, but even years later the members of his village remained unharmed, and after the fifth year of no contact Walter quietly convinced himself of his brother’s death. Fortunately, with the Elberos clan, Walter had found a community.

              After the second decade Walter began to take his aging more seriously – parts of his hair were beginning to gray, and he couldn’t move quite as nimbly as he once had. His anxiety at this was exacerbated by the complete lack of change visible on his friends. Virfaren had not aged a day, being an elf – and Elaith began to win more and more fights as Walter’s own reliance on his failing physical ability began to cost him. His own frustration at his stagnated growth began to run over into the academic parts of his life as well – even after all this time, he lacked the intuitive understanding of people that the other clan members wielded. During the excursions to war torn lands he found his ideas shot down or ignored by his peers – or most frustrating of all, systematically dismantled and undermined. When he complained of this to Virfaren, the elf tried to offer some consolation by sharing his own experience.

              “You shouldn’t be so hard on yourself Walter – it took me a century to even begin to develop an intuitive understanding of these issues. You just need to take your time, you’ll get their eventually.”

              “I don’t have a century,” Walter replied coldly. “I’ll be dead in thirty years,” to which Virfaren had no response.

              Another decade passed, and then a new member joined, and elf by the name of Reena. Reena was, for lack of a better term, an asshole – but she was a brilliant one. She picked up on the methodologies instantly, invented a number of novel strategies that began to show real effects when put in place, and most insultingly of all, began to make concrete progress with the Iravon halflings. Forced to travel with her to Sannad, Walter could do nothing but hold his tongue as she systematically dismantled prejudice against the Urivon and convinced political leaders to start making significant social change. She would host in depth, personal conversations with random halflings walking down the street, and by the end of it they left a little less prejudiced than they had begun. It took time, but the Sannad they left behind a year later was very different from the one Walter had known in his youth.

              Reena’s least redeeming trait, in spite of all of this incredible work, was her conviction that the work the Elderos clan was doing couldn’t be done by any species other than elves. Walter’s own lack of success, not to mention that he was the only non-elf of the clan, only served to solidify this bias. After weeks of verbal abuse and gloating on the way back to the Tegells, Walter went straight to Virfaren and demanded they excommunicate Reena.

              “She’s clearly a racist!” Walter shouted. “All she ever does is go on and on about how much better at everything elves are. Sure, she can talk justice, but she’ll turn right around and shit on the people she just helped. How can you let someone like that into the clan?”

              “I sympathize with you Walter, I really do,” responded Virfaren. “But, remember, the whole point of the Elberos clan is to accept all types of people, even the racist ones. Reena will learn in time. Elves are not so perfect, but she is young, barely seventy – I promise, she’ll come around in a century two, they always do.”

              Walter stormed away from the hut, furious, and ran straight into Reena, who had overheard the exchange.

              “Hold your imaginary horses, Walt, we need to talk. Think you can manage that temper of yours for five seconds?” Reena’s voice dripped with malice. “I still don’t understand why Virfaren keeps you around – as far as I’ve heard, you haven’t made any progress at all in the last thirty years. If anybody should be kicked out of the clan it should be you for being so useless.”

              Walter said nothing, staring defiantly back at the elf.

              “Well, I suppose it’s not really your fault. Maybe things will start to click in another decade or two. Two bad you’ll be dead by then.” Reena laughed to herself. “Anyways, I am actually getting tired of you staring daggers at me all the time, so I’m going to go ask to have someone actually useful the next time I go to Sannad and solve your halfling problem. I really don’t think you’re cut out for this Walt – you should consider something easier. Maybe fishing?” Reena giggled again and moved to walk past him.

              It took everything in his willpower just to stand there. Walter had never been so insulted and belittled in his life – and it was made all the worse that there was a part of him that agreed with her. He told himself that he just had to stand here, and then he could go and find a tree and calm down for a few days, having been at his limit for a while. Just as he was about to walk away, however, he heard Reena mutter under her breath.

              “Just as dumb as his brother.”

              Walter blanked out – and once he regained his bearings, he found himself straddling Reena’s bloodied corpse, staring at the crushed remains of her head. He dropped the rock he didn’t even realize he was holding and got up, only to fall back down and slowly back away from the body. He turned to his side and vomited, and at some point between dry heaves he realized Virfaren was next to him. His old friend said nothing, instead roughly pulling him up by his arm and pushing him towards the forest. Once they had reached the edge of the clan’s territory, away from the rest of the horrified clans-elves, Virfaren shoved Walted hard, who fell to his knees.

              “Reena was wrong for what she said. But you let your emotions get the best of you. Leave now before I do the same.”

              Walter slowly got to his feet and made eye contact with Virfaren. The elf was emotionless – but fire was crackling in the palm of his right hand. Saying nothing in retort, Walter stumbled away, and didn’t look back until he was as far away as his legs would take him. Exhausted, he forced himself, out of habit, to climb up a tree and immediately fell asleep.

              He did not awake in the same tree. Instead, he found himself on a cold, damp surface in pitch black. Panicking, he flung his arms out, trying to get his bearing, but found no nearby walls. Feeling around on the ground, he quickly realized he was surrounded on all sides by water. Having nowhere to go, Walter was weighing his chances on trying to swim his way out when he suddenly heard the overpowering roar of hundreds of gallons of water erupting in front of him, and just in time he latched himself onto his tiny landmass as waves of water rushed over him, completely soaking him. Shivering, he listened intently for the source of the eruption, but heard nothing but the splashing of water against a distant wall echo throughout what must have been some gigantic cavern. Suddenly, a mind-bending migraine pierced Walter’s skull, and a high pitched whine drowned out all thought while he writhed on the ground in pain, almost falling into the water and drowning himself. Then, just as quickly, it stopped, and a voice forced its way into his head.

              “Walter – can you hear me?” asked the voice, sounding surprisingly mundane, oddly similar to his brother.

              “Yes?” He croaked out, confused. “Arthur is that you?”

              “I am not your brother – I am merely pulling his voice out of your memory in order to comfort you. But you can call me Arthur.”

              “If you’re not my brother, then… what are you?”

              There was a pensive silence for a while, and Arthur could hear the sloshing of water a few dozen feet away from him. Whatever was out there was big – very, very big.

              “I… am one of the first beings to swim this earth. You will know in due time, but you are not ready. Not yet.” Something splashed into the water, and the displaced water swept past Walter, who was too drenched at this point to notice.

              “I brought you here because you’re special Walter.”

              “I’m not special,” Walter retorted, temporarily distracted by an intense self-loathing. “I’m just the same as anyone else.”

              “Biologically, yes. Humans are inferior creatures. Even in comparison to other humanoids, they are middling at best. Terribly short life spans, limited ability to pass on knowledge, not to mention weak. A miracle, frankly, any have made it so far. You realize humans are weak too, but not for these reasons. You are frustrated by your own, and, well, your races’, shortcomings. You see endless patterns of division and conflict – generations of stupid, pointless wars, the same mistakes made over and over. You think that humans should know better. You also think that halflings should know better, and maybe a few choice elves. Well, one less now anyways.” Laughter echoed in Walter’s head.

              “Your analysis is correct: humanoids – comically egotistical, by the way, and the presence of which in the human lexicon proves the point of their shortsightedness – are too stupid to see the consequences of history. Perhaps some individuals will learn the hard way not to repeat their ancestor’s mistakes, but generally those that do make the mistake don’t live long enough. That’s what this comes down to really – that humans have to make the mistake in order to learn the lesson. Unfortunately, most lessons are fatal, and those that are not can take many times a human’s lifespan to demonstrate their consequences.

              “You think that elves are better than humans because of this. Also correct: although to me, they pass their lives just as quickly. Longer lives means more time to understand consequences. Beyond that, they are not so much better. You want their intelligence – but let me tell you this, what you really want is knowledge. The kind that accumulates over endless eons of existence. These elves you admired know nothing. Knowledge is just a game of time, Walter. Let me help you win it.

              “I cannot myself give you the gift of immortality – however, it is not as hard to achieve as you may think. For now, I can transfer your consciousness into a copy of you from an alternate plane that is not so, well, decayed, and that will give you a little bit of extra time. You will have to relearn some of your skills, though, but that’s a small price to pay for a fresh body.”

              As soon as the voice stopped, the high pitched whine from before began again, more intense and furious, and Walter once again fell to the floor in pain. Suddenly he was standing, and all at once every nerve fired in his new body and he screamed in agony. The whining stopped, and Walter staggered, catching himself again from falling off his rock. He put his hands to his face and felt the skin of a much younger man: the wrinkles smoothed out, welts from his skirmishes with Elaith removed, and the aching of his joints cured instantly.

              “You have already killed once – for humans, it gets easier after the first. You will have to kill many more times, so don’t let yourself get caught up in your self-pity. Embrace your anger while you still can – I’ll warn you now, you won’t feel much after your first couple of eons. Now go, my champion, and with your own hands achieve apotheosis. Then, come back to me and I will share with you my timeless knowledge – and then perhaps we can move beyond this material plane. Oh, and I suppose you may find out what happened to your brother after all.”

              “Where do I go?” Walter asked out loud to the darkness.

              The whining began a final time. “Where all roads lead,” the voice replied.

My Garden

Have you ever questioned something you knew made no sense to question? Or, if you’re more self-aware than me, maybe you’ve wondered about your own perception of something that seems to change but doesn’t. I’ve spent my whole life living right on the coast, in a small town called Lavendale situated at the crest of a giant cliff side facing the water, with my house on the best spot right below the the tiny garden at the top of the hill. The garden is full of lavender and dahlias and rhododendrons that the locals maintain out of habit and some small pretense of tourism. In reality people hardly ever visit because there are far better views 25 minutes north to the state park, so this little garden was all mine. During the day Mr. and Mrs. Wexley might walk up for the exercise, and Amber and George would spend their early retired mornings tending to the plants, but everyone was asleep by eight thirty at the latest, so I got the evening all to myself.

               I never cared too much about the plants – I appreciated their presence, and the sense of privacy they gave the lookout point, but it was never about the plants. Rather, it was about the paradox of anxious and excited mystery of the ocean, and the rhythmic breaking of water rushing into the cliffs below, and the smell of the salt water all wrapped up in an exquisite sensory bundle that either relaxed or inspired me, depending on my mood. All this so that even when it was an especially chilly night, or drizzling, I would walk up that path behind my house with my flashlight and up to the garden and sit on the cold stone bench underneath the cedar that marked the transition to the forest and watch and listen and feel.

               When I was a kid I would have sworn that path was never ending. My parents would walk me all around town but after two or three times of dragging me up the hill to the garden I would kick and cry and scream until they figured it wasn’t worth the effort and gave up all together. It wasn’t until I was 12 or 13 that my dad told me I wasn’t cut out for the intense physical demand of what really amounted to only a 20 minute walk that I set out to prove him wrong and never stopped. Once it became a staple of my daily routine I began to jealously guard it from the stray outsiders that found themselves in Lavendale on the way to somewhere more interesting. My neighbors I could forgive but not the sullied, grimy presence of frugal hikers in their discolored 2000s Subaru Outbacks and decade-old tattered and frayed hiking boots. I remember once when I was 14 I saw a couple of guys sitting in the diner I didn’t recognize and beelined up the hill and crouched behind the towering rhododendron that framed the northeastern part of the garden telling myself I would scare them off with rocks or ghost sounds or something. But when they made their way up, surely on the recommendation of Elda, the loquacious owner of the aforementioned diner, I chickened out and just watched them look around instead. They were courteous enough to ignore me, and instead snapped a couple shots of the view and went on their way – and along with the anger I expected at the violation of my scenic viewpoint I also was disappointed they didn’t seem to appreciate it more.

I’ve been to the city before – brought on a school field trip to see the Pacific Science Center and Pike Place and the sculpture garden overlooking the waterfront. It was fun until some crazy guy started screaming at people on the street. Disheveled and dirty, reeking of dried urine and vomit, I was taken aback at his anger at random people. I made the mistake of making eye contact, and I’ll never forget the look of vitriol, the pure, unadulterated intensity and fury. I latched onto my friend’s hand and quickly looked away. My classmates joked nervously after we had safely passed but I was disturbed, that night and for a long time afterwards. I was afraid. What was his family thinking letting him soil himself in the streets? What had I done to deserve that angry look? How dare he make me feel that way!

For a long time I was afraid of going back up to my garden, becoming paranoid that this strange, horrible man somehow followed me back to Lavendale and was hiding in the big patch of roses on the southern side, just waiting to jump out and do terrible things to me. It wasn’t until my mom whispered defeat under her breath as she looked away from me and out the window towards the city that I decided to go back and watch the ferries trudge through the water.

The funny thing is that every time I went, the walk to the garden got shorter and shorter. I would go so often I wouldn’t even notice the time go by – the winding path through this sliver of forest just became the sign that marked the entrance and the big boulder covered in moss and lichen to the side by the ferns and the sharp turn you had to do behind another giant cedar, not the one in the garden, which meant you were almost there and suddenly you were. But it’s funny because if you try to think about how short the walk was it became much longer again. The way the branches intertwined by the entrance above your head and the rotting stump with someone’s initials carved into it and the strangely curved trunk of a Douglas fir you could almost sit on but not quite but also the stubborn nagging in your head that told you it was an inconvenience to walk any further, and how much better it would be to just go home instead of wasting your time outside. If you think too much about every step of exertion required to go up the path, you won’t go up the path.

               Sometimes I am so tired. There’s this feeling of defeat that looms and overtakes or drags or craftily coerces you into your house and once you’re sitting down in your ridiculous recliner or your bed you just… stay there. This isn’t the kind of tired you get from running for an hour or from walking around all day carrying shopping bags – it’s the kind of tired that sticks with you when you wake up and don’t drink enough coffee until you feel like laying down on the side of the road in front of your neighbor’s house because it’s just too much effort to even get home. It’s the kind of tired too that even if you miraculously make it back somewhere socially acceptable in which to collapse you can’t relax because you feel so bad about doing nothing so you distract yourself with books or tv or anything because you won’t be able to fall asleep and get rested no matter what.

               When I climb up to my little garden I feel good. I’ve told myself time and time again that it makes me feel good – I understand it objectively, and intuitively once I make it to the top. But even if I really know it, there is this grimy, viscous something that keeps me from going. Sometimes I feel so light and energetic and excited and inspired I’ll fly up that path in no time, and other times my foot is caught in the slime and I convince myself it’s not worth the effort. There is something about our collective human psyche that keeps us from doing the things that we know will make us feel good. I’ve heard it called activation energy, a miniature decision, very much in a way the opposite of procrastination or instant gratification. There must be something wrong with me that prevents me from acting on that. The grime is just too thick some days.

               My mother is not an especially beautiful woman. I’ve read enough cheesy coming of age stories about boys glorifying their young mother that always came off to me as rather perverse, sickening implications of sexuality – in any case, this was not an issue, both because I had no male siblings and, like I said, my mom was not pretty. She wasn’t pretty in a lot of ways, I should clarify: she was tall, taller than me, but steadily had been putting on weight ever since she hit her 30s. She slept very little, so always had bags under her eyes, and at some point she stopped using even the littlest bit of make up to touch up the acne scars she had acquired in her youth. Her nose was somewhat hooked, her eyelashes could have been longer, and she stopped trimming or controlling the lip hair that got just the faintest bit thicker every day. All of this, I admit, made me extremely vain about my own appearance – many years of too much makeup, hours spent examining myself in the bathroom mirror, looking for just a trace of any my mother’s unfortunate phenotypes.

               Over time I’ve come to accept that part of my mother’s appearance is not under her control – the nose, the mustache; it all is insignificant, in the end. But my mother is ugly in many ways, and her other form of ugliness reflects itself in the way she eats and drinks and refuses to sleep. My mother is miserable. Not for any good reason, her husband is alive and well, she has one mostly competent child, she lives in a beautiful little town surrounded by nature and water, and lives thousands of miles away from the family that she hates. But if I sometimes have my foot stuck in the tarpit, she has submerged completely long, long ago.

               So one day she divorces my father and uses her savings to rent an apartment out in downtown Seattle with a view, convinced that her problem was location. But it wasn’t, and for all the problems Lavendale may have with racism and incessant gossip Seattle has both and more. I remember visiting my mom and she was looking out the window in her new studio that she could only have been able to afford for a couple of months and I argued and pleaded and cried and still she looked out the window towards the city and whispered, under her breath, that she would never be happy, something I only barely caught because I had finally stopped sobbing, and then she

               So I went back to my garden, because I wasn’t afraid of that homeless man anymore, and I watched the moon shine for all her children. That night it was perfect: just cold enough to send a shiver down your spine every so often, even with a coat, and it had just rained during the day so it smelled of dirt and moss and the forest. I remember hugging myself and almost vomiting and trying not to make too much sound because I absolutely could not stand someone else’s presence, and in between the pain I would see the stars and hear the water and taste the air all from my little garden until years and years and years later it was OK. And now, the walk up to my garden is the shortest walk in the world.

The Tunnel

If you walked far enough away from my house, nested away in the forest, and started to walk towards the city, the first thing you would notice would have to be the walls. I live on high ground, you see – I like being close to the sky, because it makes me feel like I can go anywhere, even if all I do is sit and stare at it. It’s not so much about actually doing it… it’s really just about the feeling, you know? Anyways, you would notice the walls because you’re walking down this giant mountain and starting to go below ground so the city planners built these giant walls to lead you in. Maybe it was pretty in a weird, creepy way back when it was brand new but now it’s just gross in a weird, creep way. There’s all kinds of stuff splattered against the walls – weird paintings, people’s names carved in way above your head somehow, food rarely. You go farther and farther down and eventually you get to the ceiling, which has really bright lights installed so don’t look directly at them. Instead you keep going and realize that the stuff on the walls start to change. Closer up to the entrance, closer to the forest, the paintings were all about trees, and animals playing, one or two showing people jumping into a pond that you can see out my window at the mountain top, and lots about the sky with all its stars and clouds and magic. Once you get below ground there’s still animals but they look a lot meaner, and the paintings become more crude drawings showing animals killing people or vice versa. This is because all the people that decided to live below ground were the ones that got tired of fending off nature. They’re the farmers who lost all their crops to insect swarms and rabbits, or the unlucky few that had been attacked by wolves or bears while they were travelling, or sometimes just people who visited more developed areas and realized you didn’t have to shit out in the woods on rainy days. So they got tired of all that stuff and moved away, but fortunately for historians and not so fortunately for the greater artistic world never lost their taste for creative expression and so vented their frustration not just on the Earth by building a giant tunnel into her but also by decorating that tunnel with all of their hatred. It gets… worse, the farther down you go. Instead of just normal day to day killing of animals or being killed by animals people start putting up weird sex stuff with animals, almost like rape-revenge fantasies sometimes, or where they exaggerate that whole relationship and wallow in their own self-pity and suffering so that they imagine all of these horrible and disgusting things happening to their mangled corpses. So you keep walking down this long, long hallway, for miles and miles and miles, and you pass these big gates that you have to wait for the guards to open for you, and eventually you reach a fork in the road. Now this fork will either take you to the nice pretty city on the left or to something far less pretty and nice on the right. You can go right ahead and go to the city and watch pretty pictures on giant screens and buy all the great jewelry straight out of the surrounding mines and eat all this expensive food they have shipped down in giant elevators that lead back up to the top. But that’s not what this story is about – so you take the right. There aren’t as many lights down this way – it goes to one of the big mine shafts that was eventually deemed structurally unsound and so was abandoned fairly early on in the city’s life. So you keep going and the walls turn from cement and stone into dirt and wooden support beams, and there’s really not any paintings because the people that live here don’t really have anything to paint with. Instead you start to smell piss and shit and vomit because nobody’s gonna go walk thirty miles to the outside to use the restroom and if they tried to go to the city they’d be shot. You walk and walk and walk and last time I was there all the lights for the last few miles were out so hopefully you brought a light of your own and then you reach this bigger living space. Here you turn off your light because in this area are these little orbs of light that float around and illuminate sunken eyes and ragged beards and hopeless faces. There’s not very much to eat, you see, so instead people have to walk all the way out here to slowly starve and thirst to death. And in reality, these lights are just some unexplainable natural phenomenon but you can’t help but feel like there’s something significant about the fact that they only show up in this shithole mine shaft full of dying exiles from society. That once you’ve forsaken nature, and subsequently, ironically but also fittingly, been forsaken by people, you are given the small mercy of little dancing lights to lull you into the afterlife. I always try to take some of these people with me but they’re too sunken and ragged and hopeless to move. They spent all their energy coming here because this is all they knew what to do – as if they’ve forgotten that the outside world exists, and are simply willing to follow what they know to their death instead of realizing that there’s a better way. But there’s nothing I can do or say to convince them so instead I sit down and give out some scraps of food and water that are usually ignored and watch the little lights dance for the dead.

Joy

I was watching a ted talk recently [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iB4MS1hsWXU&feature=share] where a man talked about the way he handled a divorce in his middle ages, and all of the ensuing loneliness that entailed. He described being at home on the weekends with nothing to do and no one to talk to – tortured silence and solemn depression. In response, he discovered a group of people who emphasized connections with others. These ‘weavers’ demanded physical contact as a greeting, and tore down the many barriers that make the most guarded of us so terribly unhappy. Similarly, he described naturophiles that satisfy whatever is missing within us since birth with beautiful mountain views and long, forested treks. In his talk he asked the audience to consider these people and understand that they have something that most other people do not.

What strikes me the most, though, of this story that juxtaposes the downright cruel way we force ourselves to live, is this notion that happiness is inherently temporary. Certain ephemeral things make us happy – a compliment, a good laugh, winning a game or a fantasy football league or whatever. Joy, though, he claims, is the “…dissolution of self.” To clarify, the state of mind where you can put all of your body and mind and soul into something so wholeheartedly that you lose sight of yourself and your ego and your importance. All that matters is this project of yours – and more often than not it comes through service, or hiking, or other people. Whatever it is that makes you forget not just the daily woes of life but also of your own perceived self-importance that is the most destructive thing of all. The beauty of humility is the inherent acceptance that frees you from the self-inflicted pain of wounded pride.

This blog started with a question of what it meant to be happy, but perhaps happiness in and of itself is a myth. Instead, the much more important question might be that of a fulfilling life, purpose or drive, and how exactly on is meant to dissolute oneself. All those little happy moments are important for maintaining mental health, but there could be a foundation they must rest upon that allows them to accumulate into something significant over time. Let us think less of happiness then but instead joy, so that we might die content with the connections we have made rather than gripping lottery tickets pursuing pointless gratification.

Once Upon a Time in Hollywood

Tarantino’s most recent film was very good. Please donate to my Patreon, thanks.

***Spoilers!***

I kid, but only about the latter part. Once Upon a Time does a great job of capturing movie magic, both of itself and of the many clips that are seen within the film itself, while still pondering the joys of acting and the foundational hierarchy of Hollywood. There are many angles from which to analyse the movie as well – from a position of controversy, as historical fiction, as a critique of masculinity, or perhaps as a shameless endorsement of it. The former is well explained in this Vox article https://www.vox.com/culture/2019/8/15/20759084/once-upon-a-time-in-hollywood-controversy-bruce-lee-sharon-tate-women-explained-tarantino, for those interested. What I want to write about however is a touch of the latter two, and more, as a technique, the means of immersion within what makes movies so entertaining.

To get the first stuff out of the way, Pitt’s character Cliff is the height of Americanized masculinity: he’s shredded, poor, disdainful of annoying women, willing to put people in their place and stand up for injustice (with violence), honorable enough not to have sex with an underage teenager, lovably fond of his dog, unshakably loyal to his best friend Rick Dalton, and perhaps most importantly capable and willing to stand up for himself when threatened. The only thing he’s missing is a gun!

This trend of glorified poverty has generally seemed to have passed, but it was definitely present in movies from a few decades ago, such as in Toby Maguire’s Spiderman movies. Today, there is still certainly an ideal blue collar worker, someone who understands the struggles of the impoverished life style, that is ‘real’, and who continues to work hard in spite of all the obstacles. Someone with grit, integrity, and machismo to spare.

Taking all this into account, it’s no surprise that Cliff is kind of written in as the real worker behind the scenes – he’s the one that does all the dangerous stunts while Rick Dalton acts pretty, and in the end is the one who does all the hard, dirty work of dispatching the Mansonites while Dalton relaxes in his pool. This is further emphasized with Rick’s heightened, by contrast, emotions – a tendency to cry, and fairly quick to anger and frustration with himself. Cliff is the juxtaposition – calm and cool and always composed, even in the most dire of circumstances.

What is interesting too is the way Cliff embraces his own lower position, comforted perhaps by the knowledge that he is honorable and loyal, and so doesn’t mind the terrible pay or unsung hero-like aspects of his career. He just does his job, and is a good friend, and so ultimately is endearing.

Now, as for the counterpoint to this portrayal of masculinity, there are two major things that come to mind. First, the likely possibility that he murdered his wife: a clip is shown once this is revealed to the audience where Cliff sits on a boat with his wife and takes a barrage of verbal abuse that serves to justify the apparent outcome. To be honest, I read that as a fairly blunt admittance of the crime, and it does explain how casually he engages in violence throughout the rest of the film. Isolated from the rest of movie history, this kind of nonchalant attitude towards murder, in which someone being an annoyance is rationale enough to kill them, is one of those things that only really holds up in the fantasy of the movie – few people really want that in somebody they know in real life, because what happens if you become that annoyance? This is the curious intersection that Tarantino employs that I want to explore more in depth later, where he embraces movie tropes, and then lets them speak for themselves about their significance culturally and contextually. With the rest of movie history in mind, the trend of masculinity to equate itself with this sort of sexist generalization of certain types of women stands out like a sore thumb, and, intentional or not, highlights the issue. All that being said, within this movie fantasy, the humor and logic of the movie makes this somewhat forgivable – and that’s part of the point. Movies will forgive Cliff for being hyper-masculine, even if that’s not really a desirable real-life trait. Similarly, although I suspect this is a very personal opinion, I could not help but cringe during the final murder spree at every gruesome smack of the Manson hippie against various platforms and walls around Dalton’s house. It works in the movie, but despite the way Tarantino stylizes his violence, still is very intense. Hugely entertaining and morbidly hilarious, and yet in your face and disturbing.

Now, Cliff aside, this brings up the question of the lengths, as a director, you want to immerse yourself in this movie magic. This includes humorous violence and hyperbolic American ruggedness – these can make a movie, but at a cost. Entertainment can be highly influential, although not to the degree to which some might claim. Media can never be the sole major contributor to any level of violence within a population, but it can alter mindsets that emerge over time and in conjunction with a plethora of other influences and variables. So the qualms with sexism and racism and so on about this movie are valid – however, there must also be taken into account the way a movie is constructed as a whole, and sometimes the vision with which it is made is embedded within these issues, because that’s the point. Once Upon a Time is about recreating an era, and this era had issues, so part of representing it accurately is about engaging with them in the way they were represented. There are different ways to do this, but I don’t think that a direct critique or blatant parody is the only option. Sometimes, it’s just about showing, and making a damn fine movie in the process.

Catch-22

Recently finishing Catch-22, I’ve been taken aback by the ability of an author to convey emotion. I have not been reading as much as I should be, which is to say it has been a while since a book has really struck the right chords, and so any book really is a welcome thing, but regardless Joseph Heller created something truly incredible with his novel. For those unaware Catch-22 is a story about World War 2 – but instead of handling pre-war apathy from the West or carefully written anti-war post cards left around Germany, it dealt with a pilot, Yossarian, stationed out in Pianosa, a tiny island off the east coast of Italy, and the various army officials he has the displeasure of interacting with.

First and foremost, Catch-22 is a pleasure to read: it boasts a delightfully unique satire, and an unrivaled mastery of sophistry that will grow on you as you progress through the book. In addition, there’s a certain rhythm to his writing that highlight his major plot points, such as the girl hitting Orr over the head with her shoe in Rome, or Nately’s whore and her kid sister, or the soldier all in white, not to mention Yossarian’s constant return to the hospital – and, of course, most importantly, Catch-22 itself, the ultimate sophism. These become established early on, constantly keeping you guessing, and then once you find out what they really were everything all falls into place, not just from a plot oriented stand point, but from a thematic one as well.

To elaborate more on Catch-22, it’s a catch in any argument that means you have to do whatever the army tells you to do. The best example is that the only way any of the pilots can get out of flying more missions is to be declared insane, since any other injury can be treated in the hospital and means you can be returned to the field. Of course, any one that asks to be sent home (since this process won’t be done automatically) under the presumption that they’re crazy clearly are not crazy, because they’re asking to return home from a dangerous, life threatening war zone, and to recognize that is obviously to have complete mental faculty, and is therefore prevented from leaving. It’s ironic on so many levels because the military in this case recognize the danger they’re putting men through, but then does everything in their power to push people into the battlefield regardless. In addition, clearly they are aware of their hypocrisy of their argument, but even though it requires that acknowledgement of a contradiction to make it in the first place, they still play stupid.

I really should write up a thorough analysis of the major themes of the book, because there’s really a lot to talk about. Most notable is Yossarian’s plan to escape – recognizing that he can’t fight the army, and that he must instead escape the vicious system all together. Then there is Milo Minderbinder, a cook that develops an ‘enterprise’ in which he trades goods around Europe for incredible profits, and who ends up ordering attacks against his own base with the eventual consent of his superior officers since, supposedly, everyone gets a share of the profits – which really only makes me thing of the highly common trading of weapons to certain foreign empires that have been known to pay for attacks against us and other countries from the west (Saudi Arabia, if that wasn’t clear). There is the significance of Nately’s whore, who finally falls in love with Nately in the end but upon hearing of his death becomes determined to kill Yossarian – symbolic of his own guilt by association, perhaps, but also of the irrational responses many have to grief. In addition, there is something very profound about the way this novel depicts horrible things, and leverages those to make a statement about, obviously, the whole war thing in general, but also about it’s characters. Yossarian is a man profoundly changed by war, actually very empathetic but highly disturbed due to the death of his peers and first hand experience with the worst of war, and people themselves.

The major thing, at the end of it all, is that I can never understand how war continues after books like these come out. They so beautifully and powerfully criticize and undermine war, and make such an impact on the world, that it makes you wonder that even the creation of art like this isn’t enough.